Steak • Seafood • American • Bar-lounge
"We chose American Cut as a fancy dinner to celebrate my sister getting engaged. Our reservation was for 8pm and we didn't get seated until about 9:15 during the wait we were allowed to sit in the bar area which was extremely noisy with lots of happy hour bros (seriously, not a woman in sight lol) but they were kind enough to comp us our first round of drinks while we waited. Once seated in the dining room the noise level was much more tolerable. They brought out some everything bagel biscuits with a delicious butter and they were so good we requested another round. We ordered steaks which were pretty good. I ordered the best mashed potatoes of my life (I think called pureed potatoes Robuchon on the menu) and everyone else was really pleased with their sides as well. We were also given the steak tartare appetizer for free which was great and at the end we were given a salted caramel dessert for free even though we declined dessert menus. All in all, we were there for 3.5 hours which was way longer than we expected but the restaurant was extremely generous with making it worth our while with little freebies and also all the food we ordered was very good. It's also located only about a block from T Swift's Tribeca apartment in case that sort of thing matters to you!"
