"My wife and I were feeling hungry and thirsty after watching a boys basketball game at Geneva High School, where they had a great win that night. We asked one of the teachers for restaurant recommendations nearby, and she enthusiastically praised OTP, highlighting its food, atmosphere, and especially the must-try onion rings. She really sold us on the place, but I’m getting ahead of myself.
The directions she gave us were spot on, and when we arrived, it was a quiet evening. We ordered a beer and a mixed drink; my Stella was refreshing and flavorful. My wife enjoyed her mixed drink too, which had the perfect balance of Tito's vodka and cranberry juice—not too strong but just right. She loved it so much that she ordered a second one, which she declared outstanding.
For dinner, I chose the wings while my wife ordered the OTP burger with a side of onion rings. She really enjoyed the burger, saying it was cooked to her liking and juicy, with a delightful blend of flavors and crunch. As for my chicken wings, they were absolutely amazing—fresh, flavorful, and perfectly moist without being greasy or over-fried. I loved being able to mix and match the seasonings; the spicy BBQ, hot BBQ, and plain BBQ were all excellent.
The onion rings exceeded our expectations—fresh with a perfect amount of delicious beer batter. They were simply irresistible!
The restaurant has a warm, friendly vibe reminiscent of a Cheers bar, and it’s definitely our go-to spot for our next visit to the area. Overall, this place is EXCELLENT!
Parking: Easy parking available on Main Street.
Kid-friendliness: Offers kid-friendly meal options."
