"We were really looking forward to trying Edgewater! We made a reservation and arrived early. The bartender who served us at the high-top table mixed a wonderful old fashioned. However, the corn fritters seemed to be reheated and were presented almost burnt and barely warm. My jambalaya was clearly also reheated, just lukewarm, and the rice was still cold! My friend's pork medallion was genuinely laughable—it was just one small, lone medallion. With so many great dining options available, we can't recommend Edgewater aside from the old fashioned. Let’s be honest, we live in Wisconsin, and plenty of bars serve excellent old fashions. Overall, it’s not worth your hard-earned money!"
