Alfredo's Pizzeria - Menu

200 E 2nd St, Salem, OH, 44460, United States

🛍 Pizza, Wings, Pizzeria, Sandwiches

4.5 💬 641 Reviews
Alfredo's Pizzeria

Phone: +13303321400

Address: 200 E 2nd St, Salem, OH, 44460, United States

City: Salem

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 641

"Best wings that I've had, hands down. Oven cooked, not fried, so that makes them much better in my opinion. Sauce options are great, and they never come out overly soaked, or undercoated. My wife absolutely loves getting a Calzone. They come out very good size, and with a good amount of fillings. We both also like to get pizza from here, which is really great, because we each have far different tastes as far as sauces, and opinions on crusts, but Alfredo's is a place where we are both equally happy when getting a pizza. I've also tried their sandwiches, and salads. Neither of which have left me disappointed. For such a small place, they really do have huge flavors. And I really did expect to pay more. Their prices are not high at all."

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Salads

Extras

Calzones, Garlic Knots & Rolls

Chicken

Panini (Sandwich)

Wing-Dings

Gyros

Chicken Wings

Kids Meal - Appetizers &Amp;Amp; Sides

Starters

Calzone

Snacks And Sides

Mexican-American Food

Fingerfood

Side Orders

Uncategorized

Pizza

Pasta

Bakery

Super Gyros (Secret Menu)

Desserts

Wings

Traditional Pizza

Wings & Fingerz

Calzones

Stromboli

Oriol Oriol

Tor Pizza has friendly staff who are always accommodating, but unfortunately, the food leaves much to be desired.

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Nicolas
Nicolas

I've had a disappointing experience with the pizza here, as it's been subpar almost every time my family has ordered.


Daphney
Daphney

Friday's pizza and wing special is one of the best in town! The staff is always super nice and the food is excellent.


Estevan
Estevan

My first time trying this pizza in 38 years, and gheez, I've been missing out! Sauce and crust are perfection. You've gained a new customer for life. View menu


Carolina
Carolina

If I could give no stars, I would. The food is good, but they close whenever they feel like it. This is really frustrating, especially when you’re craving their pizza and wings, and they suddenly decide to close at 8 PM.


Merlin
Merlin

Best pizza and subs I have ever had. They are always Fast and efficient and always give the most amazing customer service! Not to mention they have great prices! I Highly recommend this place over any other pizza place in Salem


Imelda
Imelda

Best pizza place around! Great food and a wonderful staff to serve you with anything you order! Definitely a weekly family eat out place for us! Pepperoni rolls are stacked and a favorite for my kids! Clean environment and wonderful service! Highly recommend!! View menu


Estevan
Estevan

Update: Rich Garlic Pizza Sauce has earned its spot in the 5-star club! I highly recommend this place for true pizza enthusiasts. I just tried the stuffed pizza and added extra sauce and cheese, and it was fantastic! The dough around the edge was a bit undercooked, but the middle was perfect. This is a 5-star place that every real pizza lover must try!


Taura
Taura

Every time I visit this pizza shop, I feel as though they’ve known me forever! The man with black hair always treats my daughter to a soda. We stopped by for lunch today, and a young woman was working there. She was incredibly friendly! This spot is perfect for a quick lunch or for feeding the whole group on Fridays. I highly recommend it! And definitely try the PIG!


Nicolas
Nicolas

Best wings that I've had, hands down. Oven cooked, not fried, so that makes them much better in my opinion. Sauce options are great, and they never come out overly soaked, or undercoated. My wife absolutely loves getting a Calzone. They come out very good size, and with a good amount of fillings. We both also like to get pizza from here, which is really great, because we each have far different tastes as far as sauces, and opinions on crusts, but Alfredo's is a place where we are both equally happy when getting a pizza. I've also tried their sandwiches, and salads. Neither of which have left me disappointed. For such a small place, they really do have huge flavors. And I really did expect to... View menu

Categories

  • Pizza Delve into our perfectly baked pizzas, crafted with hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and a blend of gourmet cheeses. Each slice bursts with fresh toppings, ensuring a delightful bite every time.
  • Wings Savor our juicy, tender wings, tossed in your choice of mouth-watering sauces and served with crisp celery and cooling ranch or blue cheese dressing for the perfect flavor combination. View menu
  • Pizzeria Enjoy freshly baked pizzas with crispy crusts, savory sauces, and a variety of delicious toppings. Our pizzeria offers a wide range of traditional and gourmet options to satisfy all your cravings.
  • Sandwiches A delightful assortment of freshly made sandwiches, crafted with premium ingredients and served on artisan bread. Perfect for a quick lunch or a satisfying meal, each bite is packed with flavor and goodness.

Amenities

  • Wifi
  • Takeout
  • menu
  • Delivery
  • menu
  • Television

Similar Restaurants

J's Teriyaki Pub

J's Teriyaki Pub

613 Lancaster Dr NE, Salem, USA, United States

Menu • Fish • Soup • Meat • Cheese


"We used to love this place so much. I know they change owners and still liked the food. But yesterday, I had a bad experience with the guy working there. I am Mexican and I love spicy food. It used to be my numer 1 place for spicy chicken, but the last time I tried it it was kind of sweet only not spicy, so this time I asked my husband to tell the guys to make it a little more spicy and he did. He asked my husband if we wanted their special spicy chicken and I was ok with it because I thought since it was an ansian food restaurant I was specting asian red Chilli sauce, Sriracha etc. When I took the first bite all I could taste was the Carolina reaper sauce. I love spicy food but this chicken was not edible at all. I asked my husband to try it and he couldn't. I could only take one bite. So I went and told the guy what had happened. I told him I love spicy food but sorry that chicken was just not edible. He was upset right away and told me in a rude way that he could not exchange it or give me my money back, I told him I could pay for my order since thats what I told my husband initially, that if they didn't want to change it for another plate I was gonna order just a teriyaki plate. The guy got mad because I told him I was not expecting carolina reaper sauce in an Asian dish, common sence, and that he should have told my husband initially that the dish was made with that type of sauce. He just kept telling me that that's why he told my husband it was really spicy and that he could get rid of my food for me and if I was going to order something else. At this point I felt so uncomfortable to order more food since he was being rude. When I left he was being so sarcastic telling me bye, bye have a good night. Something like that. As I was leaving, he started talking about what had just happened to the guy that was behind me. And that was the worst part, that's not how you treat your costumers. Service: Take out Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $50–100 Food: 1 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 1"