Aurelio's Pizza - Menu

Our favorites always bring us back to this restaurant. We felt secure during the pandemic as well. The pizzas, salads, and service are consistently fantastic.

We order from Aurelio's all the time! Amazing food and delivery! Of course our favorite is the pizza but we love the buffalo bone-in wings. Best pizza around!

Very good pizza but this one tasted different from last time and also the order of mushrooms was not as Hardy as the time before ...different cooks different styles I think. Same ingredients! View menu

I'm not from the area, but I was visiting from about two hours away. After spending time at the water park with eight kids, we were searching for a pizza place where we could eat in. We unexpectedly came across this restaurant, and it turned out to be a delightful surprise. The pizza here is absolutely phenomenal!

We ordered two Fiesta-size sausage pizzas—one with green peppers and the other with onions—and they were absolutely delicious! When I called to place the order for pickup, the young lady on the phone was a joy to speak with! We live in Valpo and usually order from the Aurelio's in Crown Point since the one in Valpo hasn't been great. However, you guys at the Winfield Aurelio's are fantastic, and you’ve become our new go-to pizza place! Thank you for making our day (8/4/24)!!!

I visited this restaurant for dinner, and when we placed our order, we asked the waitress to raise the thermostat because it was freezing inside. She informed us that they couldn't adjust it and would have to call the owner or manager. Our experience was rather unpleasant. When I went to settle the bill, I requested to speak with the manager or owner. The waitress then appeared around the corner and claimed to be the manager herself, saying that the owner wasn’t responding to calls. I would advise staying away from this place; it seems they don’t prioritize customer comfort. View menu

We were there to celebrate my friend's youngest grandson's birthday. Parking: Enough parking for the inside diner's and the carryout Kid-friendliness: My friend's grandson's 11th birthday was celebrated there with family and friends.The kids were just fine. There was another large party there with young kids, and it was a low roar...lol When the food started coming out, it was very quiet and starved kids. The food and soda were coming out, and all you heard was the clinking of silverware and plates. The occasional outburst was heard because sports were playing on the big screen TV. The food was outstanding. We all had a very nice evening.

We registered tonight at Winfield location (8/5/21). We were very impressed by the pizza and the entire experience. The pizza was made perfect! It had the perfect amount of sauce (we love the sweet sauce) and other ingredients. Mike P. makes a GREAT pizza! We used to live near the original site in Homewood, so unnecessary to say we have high expectations. The pizza tasted like Joe did it again the day! We had exceptional service. Our server (Christina) was very attentive and friendly. All other team members were friendly. It takes a great team of people to run restaurant smoothly. We definitely make this a place for pizza! Great work Mike, Christina, Adrianna and Lauren!

The staff is very kind and accommodating. The place was unbelievably cold. We were literally shivering at how cold it was in there, even the staff had coats on!This is my first ever time at an Aurelio’s; the food came out and looked .. unpresentable. Flavor wise, just not good. Like at all. Very salty, the sauce was way too sweet, like cafeteria pizza. The cheese was both undercooked with a layer of overcooked cheese atop. I think they used cheddar too, which in my opinion doesn’t belong on pizza. The crust was okay, had nice undercarriage. Way too expensive too. $28 for a large pizza of the quality we got was disappointing. I don’t think we’ll be coming back as a result of these reasons.If... View menu