Caruso's Italian Pizza Shop

3545 Marietta Ave, Lancaster, United States

🛍 Pizza, Cheese, Italian, Gluten Free

4.4 💬 1958 Reviews

Phone: +17172853885

Address: 3545 Marietta Ave, Lancaster, United States

City: Lancaster

Menu Dishes: 11

Reviews: 1958

Website: http://carusospizzeria.com/silverspring/

"I ordered a gluten free sub for dinner. When I arrived they told me they were out of gluten free sub rolls but could put it in a folded pizza crust. I wasn?t interested in trying that and was going to just get the other food I ordered for my sister. Thecook told the staff member at the register he made it and she said she thought they were out of sub rolls and he just said hemade it already. It was in a cut in half soggy pizza dough. I didn?t eat it."

Full menu - 11 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Dessert

Burger

Pizza

Appetizer

Chicken

Fried Potatoes

Pasta

Starters

James James

Very affordable local pizza that has consistently tasted great for years.

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Tyler
Tyler

These guys are consistently great with the quality of their pizza and hoagies! Staff are always nice and the kitchen is on point ????


Brett
Brett

Great food. They get busy on the weekends but the food is worth the wait if you have one. My favorite is the meat lovers pizza. Good ingredients and staff.


Dawson
Dawson

Great food. You're busy the weekend, but the food is worth waiting when you have one. My favourite is the pizza for meat lovers. Good ingredients and staff. View menu


Zola
Zola

The best pizza and sub shop in PA. Many other great food they prepare too. I could eat here every day of the week. Thanks to all the great people that work there.


Antwan
Antwan

Have eaten here a lot. I had salads, wraps, subs hot and cold, pizza, chicken parm meal and pizza fries. All food has been very good and I will continue to go here.


Haskell
Haskell

Got our order to go on a busy Friday evening and it was ready in no time. The subs we got were very good. The sub rolls you could tell we're fresh made and they are very well made. View menu


Lydia
Lydia

Please don't ever change your gluten free hoagie rolls! Unlike a lot of them, it doesn't taste like grainy dust and it doesn't break down from moisture from meat/cheese/lettuce. Sometimes this place gets a little too busy for it's own good, but it'sworth it.


Barton
Barton

Please don't ever change your gluten free hoagie rolls! Unlike a lot of them, it doesn't taste like grainy dust and it doesn't break down from moisture from meat/cheese/lettuce. Sometimes this place gets a little too busy for it's own good, but it's worth it.


Lindsay
Lindsay

I ordered a gluten free sub for dinner. When I arrived they told me they were out of gluten free sub rolls but could put it in a folded pizza crust. I wasn?t interested in trying that and was going to just get the other food I ordered for my sister. Thecook told the staff member at the register he made it and she said she thought they were out of sub rolls and he just said hemade it already. It was in a cut in half soggy pizza dough. I didn?t eat it. View menu

Lancaster

Lancaster

Lancaster, PA is known for its Amish community and offers typical dishes like shoofly pie, scrapple, and chicken pot pie, reflecting its Pennsylvania Dutch heritage.

Categories

  • Pizza Delve into our perfectly baked pizzas, crafted with hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and a blend of gourmet cheeses. Each slice bursts with fresh toppings, ensuring a delightful bite every time.
  • Cheese A curated selection of artisanal cheeses from around the world, featuring diverse flavors and textures that delight the palate. Perfect for sharing or savored individually with the ideal accompaniments. View menu
  • Italian Savor the rich and diverse flavors of Italy with our menu, offering classic pasta, savory risottos, and traditional meat and seafood dishes, all crafted with authentic ingredients and passion. Buon appetito!
  • Gluten Free Savor delicious, gluten-free dishes crafted with fresh ingredients, ensuring taste and quality for everyone. Enjoy diverse options from appetizers to desserts, catering to gluten-sensitive needs.

Amenities

  • Pizza
  • Takeout
  • menu
  • Dine In
  • menu
  • Hoagies

Similar Restaurants

Complexity Wine

Complexity Wine

2010 W Avenue J8Ste 101, Lancaster, United States

Menu • Salad • Salads • Western • Breakfast


"The only reason this restaurant, if that’s what they call themselves, gets a star is because they have a decent wine list at a reasonable price. Otherwise, our experience tonight was absolutely miserable. A group of healthcare professionals booked a table to celebrate a milestone achievement for one of the programs at the nearby hospital. We ordered two bottles of quite expensive wine worth about $500. Never mind that they didn’t have our first choice; it happens. Then, after quite a long wait, the appetizers came. I have never seen a bruschetta served as pieces of cheap, mushy bread toast separate from the toppings, which came in a salad bowl. It was pretty much a “make your own bruschetta,” and it tasted disgusting. The olives and cheese plate were tasteless. We shrugged it off and ordered the main entrees. Five of us ordered the same main course. After at least 20 more minutes, the waitress returned to inform us that “unfortunately, the dish we had ordered is not available.” By that time, one of us, who had ordered an appetizer as an entree, left without being served because she got tired of waiting. We were quite shocked by the casual, nonchalant attitude, but as we were very hungry, we went with alternative choices, all of which arrived overcooked. Another waiter bringing the dishes had no idea who was ordering what and just threw the plates on the table. Worst of all, there was zero remorse or apology from the staff or the manager, and of course, the check had arrived in full, including the 18% “big party tip.” I won’t even go into minor details, such as the absolutely horrendous French onion soup, forgetting sugar, water, and wine glasses, etc. I don’t know if this establishment has management (no one came to talk to us), but if so, you should be ashamed of how you treated us tonight. Your staff’s attitude was ridiculous, and they obviously take no pride whatsoever in what they do. We paid in full and left. If any of you guys happen to be at the nearby hospital (God forbid), please do come see us. We will teach you what “taking good care of people” is all about, from A to Z. Shame on you for ruining our evening."