Celtic Cavern - Menu

45 Melilli Plz, 06457, Middletown, United States

🛍 Meat, Cheese, Burgers, American

4.4 💬 8292 Reviews
Celtic Cavern

Phone: +18608942954

Address: 45 Melilli Plz, 06457, Middletown, United States

City: Middletown

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 8292

Website: http://www.celticcavern.com

"This was the second time I was there and was so disappointed. I ordered a 16oz ribeye. I ate most of the ribeye and it was delicious. However, When I got to about 2 inches left I ate the top part and it tasted awful. The meat was bad. I stupidly ate another bite and it tasted like bad meat. So I let the waitress know she said but you ate most of it! I said yes and it was delicious, but that part is bad. She said she would get the manager. The manager said that was impossible! They treated me like if I was trying to get something. I said please taste it. He said no, it 's impossible that that portion was bad because you ate almost the whole steak. He asked me what I wanted from them and I said nothing, I want to let you know. The manager said he will let the chef know. When the bill came, I was charged $79 dollars for the 16 oz ribeye. I thought the waitress said $59 and it sure did not look like a 16oz. When I asked the waitress about the price, she said no, it 's $79. When I asked her about the part that a small part of the meat was bad, she screamed at me and said, That 's impossible!!!! I will never go back there again. Service is awful! Needless to say, I got a touch of food poisoning and had diarrhea all night. Also, I was really embarrassed and felt like I was doing something wrong."

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Salads

Chicken

Side Dishes

Soups

Entrées

Sides

Sandwiches

Vietnamese Specialties

Rice

Meat Dishes

Mexican-American Food

Schnitzel

Specialty Panini $8.95

Fried Rice

Seafood

Pork

Proteins

Soups And Salads

Burger

Pizza Snacks

Wraps

Beef Dishes

Dessert

Steaks

Fish Dishes

American Food

Eric Eric

Great food and atmosphere. Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Cristian
Cristian

Service: Dine-in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5


Jessica
Jessica

Got a table quickly for a group of 7, service was good and attentive, food was delish, would love to go back! Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5


Bill
Bill

1st time visit. Varied menu. Not pub food. Surely not classic Irish fare. Upscale menu but reasonable priced. Chef prepared. 19 taps, great staff. Will be back for sure! View menu


Sue
Sue

The atmosphere was vibrant and enjoyable. We experienced the best waitstaff we've ever encountered—every single person was incredibly friendly. The food was excellent! The pork chops were enormous and absolutely delicious; my husband claimed they were the best he's ever had. You can't miss the Brussels sprouts—they're a must-try!


Sean
Sean

I came across all the fantastic reviews online and felt compelled to check this place out. I was not let down. The food was excellent, particularly the artisan meat and cheese appetizers. This is definitely the spot for quality beer, and they always have Guinness on tap. I also appreciated the welcoming atmosphere and the attentive service from our servers during our visit.


Christian
Christian

I absolutely adore the food at this restaurant. Every time I visit, I make an effort to try something new, and I’ve yet to be disappointed. You simply have to order the bacon burger—trust me on this! And the steak and cheese crostinis are simply to die for. On my last few visits, the place has been quite busy, and the service took a bit longer than it should have. However, the fantastic food more than makes up for it, so that's where my complaints end! Expect to spend around $20–30 per person. View menu


Victoria
Victoria

I've always enjoyed the food at Celtic Caverns, but lately, the service and quality seem to be inconsistent. On my recent visit, I ordered a salad with marinated chicken, but I specifically requested regular grilled chicken instead. I mentioned that the chicken was too spicy and tangy for my taste, but the staff member who came over insisted that there was nothing spicy in it and tried to argue with me, which I found quite rude. During my last visit, I also experienced issues with service, as I asked for water refills twice and received cold mashed potatoes. They did eventually provide new mashed potatoes and offered something different instead of the chicken, but I still left feeling a bit...


Len
Len

The menu offered a wide range of craft beers, which you can browse on your phone. One of the specials that day was six sea scallops pan-seared with bacon and served on a bed of balsamic vinegar greens, and we absolutely loved it! My wife ordered the SHRIMP N GRITS, which included shrimp, spicy Tasso ham, cream, polenta, garlic butter, and Creole spices. It packed a nice amount of heat, and she thoroughly enjoyed it! I opted for the renowned BACON BURGER, topped with bacon, mushrooms, smoked gouda, and garlic aioli, all on a brioche bun. This may well be the best burger I’ve ever had, and I consider myself quite the foodie! It was accompanied by Celtic fries, which had the skin on and were ev...


Monica
Monica

This was the second time I was there and was so disappointed. I ordered a 16oz ribeye. I ate most of the ribeye and it was delicious. However, When I got to about 2 inches left I ate the top part and it tasted awful. The meat was bad. I stupidly ate another bite and it tasted like bad meat. So I let the waitress know she said but you ate most of it! I said yes and it was delicious, but that part is bad. She said she would get the manager. The manager said that was impossible! They treated me like if I was trying to get something. I said please taste it. He said no, it 's impossible that that portion was bad because you ate almost the whole steak. He asked me what I wanted from them and I sai... View menu

Categories

  • Meat Explore our mouth-watering meat selection, featuring expertly grilled steaks, tender chicken, and flavorful lamb dishes, each seasoned to perfection for an unforgettable dining experience.
  • Cheese A curated selection of artisanal cheeses from around the world, featuring diverse flavors and textures that delight the palate. Perfect for sharing or savored individually with the ideal accompaniments. View menu
  • Burgers Juicy, flavorful burgers crafted with premium ingredients, from classic beef to unique vegetarian options, all served with fresh toppings and a choice of hand-cut fries or a crisp salad.
  • American Enjoy classic American flavors with our diverse menu, featuring juicy burgers, crispy fried chicken, hearty BBQ ribs, and fresh salads. Indulge in timeless comfort with each bite, crafted to satisfy all tastes.

Amenities

  • Wifi
  • Debit
  • menu
  • Takeout
  • menu
  • 19 Taps

Similar Restaurants