Cumberland House Of Pizza

176 Gray Rd, 04021, Cumberland Center, United States

🛍 Pizza, Lunch, Italian, International

4.1 💬 853 Reviews
Cumberland House Of Pizza

Phone: +12078295400

Address: 176 Gray Rd, 04021, Cumberland Center, United States

City: Cumberland Center

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 853

Website: https://www.cumberlandhouseofpizza.com

"I have been coming here for a long time and always enjoyed the food and atmosphere. The original owners did a great job and were very friendly. The new owners seem nice enough, I am a bit put off by the price increases but I guess that is part of life. The food in general was pretty good for what you got. The portions are good. I have to say the pizza quality has gone substantially down and I can't say I recommend ordering it whatsoever. The other food is good enough but again it is a pizza shop so yea. but you can get a bit better price if don't mind looking elsewhere. The location is however a great spot for locals. It is easy to get in and out of which is great along with there Always plenty of parking which is nice. The inside has some seating so if you want to come in and enjoy the food you can which is nice. There is a park close by so you can grab a bite and then let the kids cut loose in the park. If you are local and want a quick bite it can be a plus but I cannot in good conscience recommend it over All with things as they are. I truly hope they go back to the care and dedication to their products and sundries that made this place great."

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Pasta

Pizza

Entrées

Salads

Subs

Wraps

Chicken Dishes

Heroes

Starters

Sandwiches

10" Toasted Grinders

Grill Se

Argentinian Beef

Stone Oven Pizza

Snacks & Appetizers

Bread

Burger

Gyros

Chicken Kabobs

Vegetarian

Finger Food

Strombolis

Dinners

Cheryl Cheryl

They continuously mess up orders! Place orders online due to pressing times and they mess up orders.

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Rebecca
Rebecca

Thin, light and crispy crust pizza, that isn't soggy. Reheats the next day for a second great meal. Love having the oregano shaker on the table. Wish they had a location near me.


Pam
Pam

Way over priced food was not good we ordered a large pizza they didn't even cut it steak sandwich was dry we ordered French fries and never got them service was not friendly and tables were dirty. We will never go back there don't waste your money!! We did not check out the bathrooms but I am sure they were not clean if the tables you eat off were not clean.


Marjorie
Marjorie

I am extremely disappointed and will not be returning! I ordered extra sauce for my spaghetti since I knew the original amount wouldn’t be enough for my taste, and I even paid for the extra. However, when I got home, there was barely enough sauce to cover the spaghetti. It just tasted like wet noodles with no flavor whatsoever. I've also tried the steak sandwiches, which were really dry. I’m finished! View menu


Lana
Lana

The food here is consistently delicious! A few of my favorites include their pizza, which is always loaded with fresh toppings, and their gyro, packed with flavor and plenty of fillings. However, tonight the tuna salad was a bit watery, which is unusual since it’s typically quite good. The fries are crispy and especially tasty when they're fresh out of the fryer. Overall, a fantastic dining experience!


Naysha
Naysha

The pizza is advertised as the best, but unfortunately, it lacks flavor. The so-called buffalo wings are overly salty and don't even resemble authentic buffalo wings. Additionally, the service from all the staff, including the manager, was quite unpleasant, making the entire experience uncomfortable. While it's the only pizza place near my home, I definitely won’t be coming back. Best of luck with Cumberland's best pizza!


Ray
Ray

Been a customer here for over 18 years. Used to be a fantastic place with amazing service. Lately seems to be staffed primarily by young, immature and somewhat rude individuals. Hope they can get back to what made them great. Once I got home with my order I noticed in addition to the rudeness the order was wrong. I ordered chicken tenders when I called and confirmed that when I paid in person. Ended up with buffalo tenders with way too much flavoring. They are simply gross and my family will not eat them. Wasted $35 dollars for this lousy experience and wrong order. They just lost a long time customer. View menu


Rick
Rick

Unfortunately, even after a year of changing hands during peak times it is unorganized not well run in here. The last several times I've ordered in here either using their online app or calling in after using this place for 15 years it's a minimum of an hour to an hour and a half wait on a Friday or Saturday night. Case in point tonight ordered a large pizza 2 toppings I was told an hour and 10 minutes, fine. I arrive after an hour and 5 minutes and they had not even started making the pizza but thought they could make room in the oven and maybe get it done in the next 20 minutes. For perspective, it's not like there was a school bus parked out front or a football game in the fields out back...


Melissa
Melissa

New ownership still struggling. I don't think I've had a correct order since the new owners took over. First time order was done online, waited an hour, went to pick up and they had no record stating there's an issue with online orders. No apologies, didn't offer anything just forced me to wait while they made it again. Next time ordered nachos to go, came home, the cheese wasn't even melted. Decided to stop ordering (a bummer since we live across the street). We just went in again after waiting 6 months. Ordered a two items, one was correct and the other was the wrong item. While they apologized, it was the third strike. After a long week, I just wanted an easy dinner. Thankfully it was my...


Matthee
Matthee

I have been coming here for a long time and always enjoyed the food and atmosphere. The original owners did a great job and were very friendly. The new owners seem nice enough, I am a bit put off by the price increases but I guess that is part of life. The food in general was pretty good for what you got. The portions are good. I have to say the pizza quality has gone substantially down and I can't say I recommend ordering it whatsoever. The other food is good enough but again it is a pizza shop so yea. but you can get a bit better price if don't mind looking elsewhere. The location is however a great spot for locals. It is easy to get in and out of which is great along with there Always ple... View menu

Categories

  • Pizza Delve into our perfectly baked pizzas, crafted with hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and a blend of gourmet cheeses. Each slice bursts with fresh toppings, ensuring a delightful bite every time.
  • Lunch Satisfy your midday cravings with our delicious lunch menu. From fresh salads and hearty sandwiches to savory soups and vibrant bowls, each dish is crafted to give you the perfect midday boost. View menu
  • Italian Savor the rich and diverse flavors of Italy with our menu, offering classic pasta, savory risottos, and traditional meat and seafood dishes, all crafted with authentic ingredients and passion. Buon appetito!
  • International Explore a world of flavors with our diverse selection of international dishes, crafted to offer a culinary journey across continents, filled with vibrant and authentic tastes from around the globe.

Amenities

  • Delivery
  • Accepts Credit Cards
  • menu

Similar Restaurants