Firehouse Subs - Menu

1701 North Mayfair Road, Milwaukee, WI 53226, 53226-3095, United States

🛍 Delis, Lunch, Fast Food, Sandwiches

4.2 💬 3474 Reviews
Firehouse Subs

Phone: +14142128913,+14149149300

Address: 1701 North Mayfair Road, Milwaukee, WI 53226, 53226-3095, United States

City: Milwaukee

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 3474

Website: https://www.firehousesubs.com/locations/wi/mayfair

"After giving birth this is all I craved. My husband picked up some food and I also ordered a pack of brownies. However when my husband arrived I asked for the brownies and then he realized that the person working his order didn’t add them. I told him to call but he’s not that type of person to complain. But I think since he paid for it he should’ve asked for the refund or asked to pick them up the next visit. But food is always good. I’m still disappointed he didn’t ask for his money back. Or the fact that I never got my brownie fix"

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Salads

Hot Specialty Subs

Dessert

Sandwiches

Build Your Own Sub

Subs

Beef Dishes

Snacks And Sides

Pizza

Most Popular

Entrées

Kids Menu

Kid's Combo

Wrap

Limited Time Offer

Hot Subs

Kids' Combo

Signature Subs

Cold Subs

Kids Combos

Medium Specialty Subs

Boar's Head Cold Sandwiches

Hot Subs & Soups

Philadelphians

Mafalda Mafalda

brisket sub. nice cutting! obviously someone wears an eyepatch

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Melissa
Melissa

Brisket sub. NICE CUTTING! Clearly someone is wearing an eyepatch


Timmothy
Timmothy

The were great as always but I have to vent a little bit The cashiers were mostly incompetent.


Hope
Hope

I grew up on meatball subs from a local hole-in-the-wall place that my parents went to while they were dating. View menu


C
C

Delicious subs! I love this location too, they always have great portions and great quality. You definitely get what you pay for. Yum!


Wyatt
Wyatt

First time at firehouse subs and 2 b honest the subs can't compete with Jersey Mike's! Firehouse Subs taste like they use Subway bread! The customer service


Dennis
Dennis

Great place for a quick meal. Staff is always friendly and the facility is clean and well maintained. The brisket sub is absolutely the best. Plenty of parking and easy to see from the street but, just a little hard go get to due to it's location. View menu


Denise
Denise

I tried the tuna fish sandwich at this Italian restaurant, and it was absolutely delicious! I've heard great things about the tuna here, and I can definitely confirm that it's as good as people say! It comes with a pickle, and I also had the Chicken Dumpling Soup, which was very tasty as well. The two guys working there were fantastic, too!


q
q

Fell in love with Firehouse Subs when I lived in San Antonio Texas. Being disabled the store goes above and beyond and brings my sandwich orders to my car. A little bit more expensive than Subway or Jimmy John's but well worth the extra price as the subs are delicious. And they also support local firefighter charities. Had only one problem, for some reason my bank card that I used rejected the donation I made. Not sure why but it did pay for the sandwich order. This is the phone app on an Android phone.


Abby
Abby

After giving birth this is all I craved. My husband picked up some food and I also ordered a pack of brownies. However when my husband arrived I asked for the brownies and then he realized that the person working his order didn’t add them. I told him to call but he’s not that type of person to complain. But I think since he paid for it he should’ve asked for the refund or asked to pick them up the next visit. But food is always good. I’m still disappointed he didn’t ask for his money back. Or the fact that I never got my brownie fix View menu

Milwaukee

Milwaukee

Milwaukee is known for its brewing history, vibrant arts scene, and diverse cuisine, including classic German fare, cheese curds, and frozen custard.

Categories

  • Delis Fresh, made-to-order sandwiches, salads, and sides with premium ingredients. Enjoy classic favorites and unique creations, perfect for a quick, satisfying meal or a leisurely lunch with friends.
  • Lunch Satisfy your midday cravings with our delicious lunch menu. From fresh salads and hearty sandwiches to savory soups and vibrant bowls, each dish is crafted to give you the perfect midday boost. View menu
  • Fast Food Enjoy a variety of quick and delicious meals perfect for on-the-go dining. From juicy burgers and crispy fries to refreshing drinks, our fast food menu satisfies your cravings with speedy service and irresistible flavors.
  • Sandwiches A delightful assortment of freshly made sandwiches, crafted with premium ingredients and served on artisan bread. Perfect for a quick lunch or a satisfying meal, each bite is packed with flavor and goodness.

Amenities

  • Takeout
  • Delivery
  • menu

Similar Restaurants

Rare Steakhouse

Rare Steakhouse

833 E Michigan Street Milwaukee, WI 53202, 53202-5607, United States

Menu • Soup • Meat • Steak • Salad


"My husband and I have made it a tradition to try different steak houses in the Milwaukee area for our anniversary. This year we decided on Rare. We loved the ambiance and our waitress was great. We had no idea when the reservation was made that Fridays they offer half off bottles of select wine and we definitely took advantage of that! The Burgess Cellars Cabernet was delicious! For our meals we decided to start out with salads. My husband is a very adventurous eater and eats everything except for onions. He despises onions. He ordered the chopped salad without onions. Upon arrival we could smell them. A few bites in and onions. We sent the salad back and a new one is brought out and guess what. More onions. The waitress said she was a bit surprised since she said she watched them remake it and we were a bit disappointed. For our meals, my husband and I each ordered the dry aged bone in rib eye and brussel sprouts with goat cheese and mushrooms in truffle oil for our sides. The sides were phenomenal. I would go back just for the sides. The steaks on the other hand were not as great as we were hoping they’d be. The char on the steaks overpowered any of the dry aged flavoring we were expecting to taste and the steaks themselves were very difficult to cut. We have never had this issue before at any of the other high end restaurants we’ve been to. This was also disappointing. All in all we rate this restaurant a The service was great (thanks Quinn), the wine delicious and the sides phenomenal. Quinn also gave us a glass of champagne to celebrate our anniversary, that was a lovely gesture. We’re glad we tried Rare but will definitely not be returning… well, maybe for those sides!"