Phone: +16316660458
Address: 553 E Main St, Bay Shore, United States
City: Bay Shore
Menu Dishes: 28
Reviews: 116
Website: http://www.fratellipizza.us/
"I recently tried food from this restaurant for the first time through Uber Eats. I was a bit hesitant because my last two experiences ordering from different pizzerias in Bay Shore—where I got calzones and pizza—were disappointing. I really didn't want a third letdown. I ordered two calzones, one with pepperoni and one with meatballs. Unfortunately, instead of meatballs, I received one filled with Italian sausage, which I hadn’t wanted. However, despite the mix-up, the calzone was actually delicious. It was filled with a perfect balance of ricotta and mozzarella, along with just the right amount of sausage. I mention this because, a few weeks ago, I had ordered from another pizzeria and their calzone was unappetizing both in appearance and taste. As for the pizza, it was well-made with a generous and balanced amount of sauce and cheese. The flavors were spot on, and the dough was baked to perfection—not greasy or soggy at all. I found the prices to be competitive and genuinely worth it; some places charge $10 more for the same size pizza. I would definitely order from this restaurant again and recommend it as a great pizzeria."
Full menu - 28 options
All prices are estimates on menu.
Entrées
Baked Clams
Fresh clams baked with herbs, garlic, and breadcrumbs for a savory appetizer.
Eggplant Rollatini
Tender eggplant slices rolled with ricotta and herbs, baked in marinara sauce and topped with melted mozzarella.
Roman-Style Stracciatella
Creamy Roman-style stracciatella cheese served fresh with extra virgin olive oil.
Salads
Greek Salad
Fresh and vibrant salad with tomatoes, cucumbers, olives, feta cheese, and a drizzle of olive oil.
Caesar Salad
Crisp romaine lettuce tossed with creamy Caesar dressing, Parmesan cheese, and crunchy croutons.
Tossed Salad
Fresh mixed greens with tomatoes, cucumbers, and your choice of dressing.
Dessert
Fried Ice Cream menu
A delightful treat, crispy on the outside, cool vanilla ice cream on the inside, drizzled with chocolate and topped with cherries.
Specialty Pies
Deserts
Calzone
Calzone
A folded pizza filled with cheese, tomato sauce, and a variety of meats or vegetables, baked until golden.
Meat Dishes
Meatballs
Juicy meatballs simmered in rich tomato sauce with herbs, served with crusty bread for a hearty meal.
Pizza
White Pizza
A savory pizza topped with a blend of rich cheeses and garlic-infused olive oil, no tomato sauce.
Whole Pizza Pies
Grandma Pizza
A classic square pizza with a thick, fluffy crust, topped with fresh tomatoes, mozzarella, and basil.
Starters
Vegetables
Seafood Dishes
Fried Calamari
Crispy golden fried calamari served with tangy marinara sauce for dipping.
Soups
Sharing
"Hot Sandwiches"
Sausage Parmigiana
Grilled sausage topped with marinara sauce and melted mozzarella, served on a toasted roll.
Stuffed Pizzas
Baked
Eggplant Parmigiana
Breaded eggplant slices baked with marinara sauce and melted cheese.
Giannina
The best Italian pizza and restaurant in Islip! The food is fantastic, and I truly adore it!
Address
Reviews
Deondre
This is the best Italian pizza and restaurant in the city of Islip. You won't want to miss out on the flavors—it's a true delight!
Angela
John has been in business for over 40 years, and there's a great reason for that! It's far superior to any upscale restaurant. You owe it to yourself to give it a try!!!
Lemuel
Great customer service, excellent food, and clean. Owners and staff are very courtious and professional. They care about their customer's satisfaction, which is a rare find now a days. And we love the pizza! View menu
Trystan
extremely friendly owners and staff who welcome you as soon as you enter. delicious pizza brought to your table. have been there twice so far, both great experiences. will definitely be trying other items from their menu.
Sally
I was quite disappointed with this dish. We frequently visit Fratellis and usually have a great experience, but their delivery options fell short this time. It was particularly frustrating to learn that I must have ordered from the Uber Eats menu.
Joshua
After nine months of living in East Islip, we finally discovered Fratelli, and it's been a relief after a series of disappointments. Their pizza sauce really stands out with its unique flavor—it has character! I believe we've found our go-to pizza spot. View menu
Gus
After nine months in East Islip, we finally discovered Fratelli after experiencing several disappointments. The pizza sauce here has a unique personality and flavor that we’ve been searching for. I truly believe this will be our favorite pizza place from now on!
Pascale
I was very disappointed with this restaurant. We frequently order from Fratellis and are usually very satisfied. However, their delivery service has been quite disappointing. It was especially frustrating when I was told that I had to go through them rather than using the Eats app? As for the menu:
Angela
I recently tried food from this restaurant for the first time through Uber Eats. I was a bit hesitant because my last two experiences ordering from different pizzerias in Bay Shore—where I got calzones and pizza—were disappointing. I really didn't want a third letdown. I ordered two calzones, one with pepperoni and one with meatballs. Unfortunately, instead of meatballs, I received one filled with Italian sausage, which I hadn’t wanted. However, despite the mix-up, the calzone was actually delicious. It was filled with a perfect balance of ricotta and mozzarella, along with just the right amount of sausage. I mention this because, a few weeks ago, I had ordered from another pizzeria and th... View menu
Bay Shore
Bay Shore is a charming coastal town known for seafood dining, with local favorites like clam chowder, fresh oysters, and lobster rolls being typical culinary delights.
Categories
-
Italian Savor the rich and diverse flavors of Italy with our menu, offering classic pasta, savory risottos, and traditional meat and seafood dishes, all crafted with authentic ingredients and passion. Buon appetito!
-
Pizzeria Enjoy freshly baked pizzas with crispy crusts, savory sauces, and a variety of delicious toppings. Our pizzeria offers a wide range of traditional and gourmet options to satisfy all your cravings. View menu
-
American Enjoy classic American flavors with our diverse menu, featuring juicy burgers, crispy fried chicken, hearty BBQ ribs, and fresh salads. Indulge in timeless comfort with each bite, crafted to satisfy all tastes.
-
North American Savor the diverse flavors of North America with dishes ranging from juicy burgers and crispy fried chicken to tangy BBQ ribs and fresh salads, all capturing the essence of regional favorites and comfort classics.
Amenities
-
Takeout
-
Delivery
- menu
