Goodfellas Pizzeria

377 Bay St Ste A, San Francisco I-94133-1901, United States

🛍 Pizza, Italian, Pizzeria, Vegetarian

4.1 💬 2310 Reviews
Goodfellas Pizzeria

Phone: +14153981000

Address: 377 Bay St Ste A, San Francisco I-94133-1901, United States

City: San Francisco

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 2310

Website: https://www.goodfellaspizzasf.com/?utm_source=gbp

"I wasn't planning to visit this pizzeria, but I felt I had to. The Pepsi was lacking sweetness, and the Dr. Pepper was flat. It took 35 minutes for our food to arrive, and the manager explained there was an issue with the oven. Okay, I understand that happens. However, when my bread arrived, I found a 2-inch long black hair in it. The manager was very apologetic, and I just wanted to make you aware of the situation. On our way out, an older employee made some nonsense remarks about me, which was frustrating—thankfully, my wife didn't mention it until we had already left. On a positive note, the dish I had was quite good. Overall, it was a unique experience."

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Pizza

Salads

Starters

Sandwiches

Bread

Chicken Dishes

House Dressings

Cold Subs

Milano's Pizza Specials

Lunch

Modern Deli Sandwiches

Danny Danny

The pizza is absolutely delicious, especially watching how they make the dough.

Address

Show Map

Reviews

J
J

Barbeque chicken pizza was exceptional. Excellent customer service and friendly.


Beth
Beth

I ordered delivery from Goodfellas Pizza and the slices were excellent. They had a lot of toppings and were very generous in size. Highly recommended!


Jason
Jason

Fantastic neighborhood pizza. Giant slices. I believe they are bigger if you dine in. Great deal for local workers. Great Phillycheese too. Definately 5 stars! View menu


Leamsi
Leamsi

The food is great!! Interesting variety of pies. It's a tiny place and the service is ok. I totally recommend it, portions are great, they have pasta and other dishes apart from pizza.


sakshi
sakshi

Will not recommend for a dine-in experience, because the place is usually occupied by homeless and very dungy. This otherwise would be a good place for families. But the 4*s are only for the food!!! Amazing pizzas...


Irving
Irving

That's a great pizza. The guys I ordered were very hospitable and friendly. When I came from the Middle West, it felt like I was back home to order from one of my local places. Very recommended. If I had this in my hometown, that would be my place. View menu


Даница
Даница

Whenever I'm in town, I always stop by this place. The service is excellent, and the pizza is absolutely delicious. One of my favorites is the Smoking Good Fellas. For something different, you should definitely try the chicken cake—it's so tasty! Yum!


Kearra
Kearra

I used to visit this restaurant almost every day, either dining in or ordering takeout since I lived nearby. Their food is absolutely delicious! Their burgers are unmatched and their pizzas are fantastic as well. I once asked them to cut my pizza to resemble a carved pumpkin and they delivered perfectly. Although it has been some time since then, whenever I am in the city, I make sure to stop by. I love the food, ambiance, and the friendly staff. I hope this restaurant remains open for a long time and is able to expand to other locations because their food is truly exceptional.


Madelyn
Madelyn

I wasn't planning to visit this pizzeria, but I felt I had to. The Pepsi was lacking sweetness, and the Dr. Pepper was flat. It took 35 minutes for our food to arrive, and the manager explained there was an issue with the oven. Okay, I understand that happens. However, when my bread arrived, I found a 2-inch long black hair in it. The manager was very apologetic, and I just wanted to make you aware of the situation. On our way out, an older employee made some nonsense remarks about me, which was frustrating—thankfully, my wife didn't mention it until we had already left. On a positive note, the dish I had was quite good. Overall, it was a unique experience. View menu

Categories

  • Pizza Delve into our perfectly baked pizzas, crafted with hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and a blend of gourmet cheeses. Each slice bursts with fresh toppings, ensuring a delightful bite every time.
  • Italian Savor the rich and diverse flavors of Italy with our menu, offering classic pasta, savory risottos, and traditional meat and seafood dishes, all crafted with authentic ingredients and passion. Buon appetito! View menu
  • Pizzeria Enjoy freshly baked pizzas with crispy crusts, savory sauces, and a variety of delicious toppings. Our pizzeria offers a wide range of traditional and gourmet options to satisfy all your cravings.
  • Vegetarian Delight in our vibrant collection of vegetarian dishes, crafted with the freshest greens, rich flavors, and savory spices. Enjoy a wholesome, delectable plate that celebrates nature's finest ingredients.

Amenities

  • Wifi
  • Takeout
  • menu
  • Delivery
  • menu
  • Barbecue

Similar Restaurants

Salty's

Salty's

748 Van Ness Ave, 94102, San Francisco, United States

Menu • Lunch • Coffee • Breakfast • Sandwiches


"Earlier this year Salty 's was featured in one of the top 100 places to eat in the Bay Area in 2022, and after trying it a couple times, it 's easy to see why. Quality and flavor, great customer service, it checks all those boxes. I occasionally visit the 24 hour fitness on Van Ness, and Salty 's happens to be just few short blocks away which makes it perfect when I 'm looking for a post-workout sandwich. And for those that know me, I love me my sandwiches. On my latest visit, I decided to go with the 'Glorious B sandwich, which come with turkey, bacon, avocado, pepper jack, veggies, and garlic mayo. The blend of flavors and high quality of the turkey is no wonder it 's at the very top of the menu list. It 's one of those sandwiches, that you can bring to park and not need a ton of napkins to get through. It was well put together, with the ratio of all the ingredients matching well. Nothing overpowering, just sandwich perfection. The size of the sandwich I thought was the perfect size for my appetite. As I 've gotten older I can 't put down as much food as I used to, and after one-half I knew I could 've stopped eating, be content, saved the rest for later. But of course I ate the whole thing and nothing sounds better than taking a quick power nap right after. I love that their menu has so many different sandwich combinations, so definitely take time to check their menu before calling-in/walking-in to order because it 'll definitely save you some time. On my latest visit, I was in and out in 10 minutes. Definitely towards the top of my list of sandwiches in this part of town!"