Gusto 46 - Menu

271 US Highway 46, Mine Hill I-07803-3029, United States

🛍 Lunch, Pizza, Cheese, Italian

4.2 💬 767 Reviews

Phone: +19736590444

Address: 271 US Highway 46, Mine Hill I-07803-3029, United States

City: Mine Hill

Menu Dishes: 17

Reviews: 767

"I normally wouldn’t write a bad review of a restaurant, but I think it is necessary this time. I used to work here when it was under different ownership. The previous owner was always very professional with customers and kept up on various tasks to keep the restaurant clean. The food also used to be amazing and I would eat there all the time. I went in today with two other girls who used to work there and we were astonished with the condition this restaurant is in. We walked in to see the new owner playing a computer game at the waitress station and did not pay any attention to his customers. My fountain coke had floating black “stuff” in it meaning the machine had not been cleaned in a very long time. Hopefully that bacteria floating in my drink doesn’t make me sick. With our wings that we ordered, I said I did not want any ranch or blue cheese, but instead all three of us were given one side of both ranch and blue cheese each…which we were charged 3 dollars for on our bill without warning. I ordered eggplant parm with vodka sauce and was charged an extra 3 dollars for the vodka sauce, again, without warning. There was one singular pizza pie on the pizza counter compared to a dozen when I used to work there. I was so disappointed with the food and how unprofessional the staff and owner was. They seemed to try and get as much money out of us as they could. On that note, I will not be coming back to this restaurant. I recommend Anthony Francos a few miles down the road if you’re looking for good Italian food. :"

Full menu - 17 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Chicken

Calzone

Specialty Pizza

Pasta

Seafood

Mexican-American Food

Sides

Calzones, Garlic Knots & Rolls

Featured Items

Sandwiches

Pizza

Chicken Dishes

Starters (Antipasti)

Personal Pizza 12"

Janine Janine

Food was cold and terrible. I give it a NEGATIVE 5 star review!

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Timothy
Timothy

Excellent food! Got the baked tortellini and it was delicious! Definitely give it a try


Jurgen
Jurgen

Another place that's always empty. Not impressed at all. I really feel things are going downhill in this country.


Kyle
Kyle

Food is always either undercooked or overcooked, and they ALWAYS mess up the pizza. Gustos has gone downhill ever since the owner left, and my family and I will NEVER get pizza or anything from them again. BE WARNED to anyone who eats there View menu


Yanni
Yanni

I just went here for the first time in a long time. I ordered the pasta fagioli soup. It looked like a bowl full of mush …not good at all. It was like creamy and super thick. You guys need to try a better recipe. I’m not one to write reviews but I was really disappointed.


Tom
Tom

The pizza is some of the best I've had in the area. My one complaint is that they put way too much flour on the bottom of the pizza like when they put it on the peel to slide it in. When I take a bite of the pizza I get a mouth full of flour. I ordered pizza there three times and it happens on all of them. If they could just get that down or maybe use semolina, I would give the place 5 stars.


Renee
Renee

Today I had my usual from Gusto 46.I work at a local surgery center and always look forward to the margarita pizza. The slice is always big full of cheese the crust is crispy and delicious. Today the pizza was horrible the crust was dry like sawdust there were 4 dots of sauce 4 dots of mozzarella cheese a sprinkle of oregano and some overcooked cheese.the pizza was so over cooked it was last like cardboard so difficult to eat. You would need a pitcher of water to swallow it. On a good note the gentleman that work there are very polite and very nice it's such a shame they are forced to serve such gross food. View menu


sabrina
sabrina

DO NOT ORDER HERE! They are extremely unprofessional. The pizza taste like it’s cheap and is undercooked yet they stated that it was brown at the bottom…. Look at all the previous reviews they are Trash. The owner is a problem as well. They told me to return my food for a refund just to tell me I have to go through doordash. I have 3 kids that are the pizza before I could even tell it wasn’t cooked right. I’m sure the owner will respond as he has under previous comments just to justify his cheap ways. DO NOT FALL FOR IT! Go to Fortes up the street no hassle and 1000000x better quality. I wanted to try a different spot and won’t ever again!


Shaun
Shaun

Since changing ownership this restaurant has gone into a complete tailspin. We always used to get Gustos all the time since it's down the street, tasted great, and was priced fairly well. The past 6 months since ownership change I've given them 3 chances. First time was on slices I didn't know of the ownership change however, it was obvious when I walked in the door and there was about 2 pies out when previously the countered was covered with 10-15 delicious looking options. Okay, so figured maybe we'll try their dinners. Even worse you can tell the ingredients don't hold the quality they previously did and the food didn't seem completely cooked all the way through. Sadly the business needs...


Aj
Aj

I normally wouldn’t write a bad review of a restaurant, but I think it is necessary this time. I used to work here when it was under different ownership. The previous owner was always very professional with customers and kept up on various tasks to keep the restaurant clean. The food also used to be amazing and I would eat there all the time. I went in today with two other girls who used to work there and we were astonished with the condition this restaurant is in. We walked in to see the new owner playing a computer game at the waitress station and did not pay any attention to his customers. My fountain coke had floating black “stuff” in it meaning the machine had not been cleaned in a very... View menu

Categories

  • Lunch Satisfy your midday cravings with our delicious lunch menu. From fresh salads and hearty sandwiches to savory soups and vibrant bowls, each dish is crafted to give you the perfect midday boost.
  • Pizza Delve into our perfectly baked pizzas, crafted with hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and a blend of gourmet cheeses. Each slice bursts with fresh toppings, ensuring a delightful bite every time. View menu
  • Cheese A curated selection of artisanal cheeses from around the world, featuring diverse flavors and textures that delight the palate. Perfect for sharing or savored individually with the ideal accompaniments.
  • Italian Savor the rich and diverse flavors of Italy with our menu, offering classic pasta, savory risottos, and traditional meat and seafood dishes, all crafted with authentic ingredients and passion. Buon appetito!

Amenities

  • Pizza
  • Pasta
  • menu
  • Wings
  • menu
  • Takeout

Similar Restaurants

Mizuki Asian Fusion And Hibachi

Mizuki Asian Fusion And Hibachi

1033 Rt 46, Ledgewood, NJ, 07852, LEDGEWOOD, United States

Menu • Pizza • Asian • Sushi • Japanese


"I recently visited Mizuki Asian Fusion and Hibachi Restaurant for a friend’s birthday celebration and was thoroughly impressed by the experience. From the moment we walked in, the welcoming atmosphere and tastefully decorated interior made us feel right at home. Despite it being a sophisticated dining spot, the restaurant was surprisingly family-friendly, a factor that significantly enhanced our evening. The pricing at Mizuki struck a perfect balance between affordability and quality. It’s not always easy to find a place that offers such value, especially with the flair and precision of Asian fusion and hibachi cuisine. Each dish we ordered was beautifully presented, bursting with flavors that paid homage to traditional Asian cuisine while introducing a unique, modern twist. What truly set Mizuki apart, however, was the attention and care the staff showed towards my 2-year-old daughter. Dining out with a toddler can be a challenge, but the staff at Mizuki went above and beyond to ensure she was entertained and comfortable throughout their captivating hibachi show. Their efforts to engage with her and include her in the experience without disrupting the service for others was remarkable and greatly appreciated. The hibachi chefs were not only masters of their craft but also brilliant entertainers, making our dining experience memorable with their skillful cooking and lively performances. Their ability to captivate the audience, regardless of age, added an extra layer of enjoyment to our meal."