Hook Reel Cajun Seafood

1756 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10303, City of New York, United States

🛍 Meat, Fries, Seafood, Chicken

3.3 💬 10 Reviews

Phone: +19178300159

Address: 1756 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10303, City of New York, United States

City: City of New York

Menu Dishes: 30

Reviews: 10

Website: https://hookreel.com/menu/

"My family and I went out to eat here and the experience was horrific. The food was just terrible.. From the appetizers to the main dishes we ordered. The menu was pretty limited and pricey for what they were offering. I ordered crab fries and it was topped with initiation crab meat. Being that this is a seafood restaurant I didn't think they would even sell fake crab. It was definitely not worth the price. The lobster bisque was cold and extremely thick.... The seafood rice was just ok.. I wouldn't order it again. After the appetizers I really wanted to cancel my dinner order. The best thing I had was the watermelon margarita. There were only 2 people working upfront.. the manager and the waitress. The manager made the drinks and the waitress took the orders for the entire restaurant. They did the best they could. I was so disappointed in this food.. especially since we paid over $300 for it. Totally was not worth it AT ALL. We usually go to the Hylan Blvd location and it's usually good. I won't be visiting again."

Full menu - 30 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Entrées

Specials

Seafood

Chicken Wings

Side Dishes

Salads

Sushi Rolls

Fried Seafood

Sandwiches

Soups

Appetizers

Seafood Dishes

Po' Boy

Sandwiches, Burgers & Po Boys

Raw Bar Selections

Snacks & Sides

Po' Boy & Sliders

Side Orders

Chicken/Fish/Shrimp

Sides

Frozen To-Go Drinks

The Fryer

Main Course

Joanthan Joanthan

Gotta say that Aaron provided my girl and I great service, the food was great, the desserts are great. Definitely gonna come here often and y’all should definitely consider giving Aaron a raise. Anyways this place is a 10 outta 10 ??

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Rudy
Rudy

It is crazy how I made my order directly on the website and they gave me a pickup eta of 7:23, I got to the restaurant at 7:30 and I've been waiting for over 1/2 hour for my food to be ready. There's people here waiting for over 45 minutes.


Gabrielle
Gabrielle

The manager Anthony and our server Ivy were very friendly, welcoming and helpful. The food was absolutely delicious and the portions were generous. The location was very clean, and well kept. The atmosphere made for a great birthday celebration for my sister. Definitely recommend!


Gipsy
Gipsy

I waitress with a female long brown hair she was suoer nice. Have reservations yesterday Friday for 6 PM. however surprisingly it was not busy whatsoever did not need reservations it was better to have. Their outdoor seating is a simple set up nothing too fancy. It was very sunny that day though thankfully I picked seats with the only shady part!! The bill was $73 for two people. Res so able pricing. It is messy though so use the View menu


Jeff
Jeff

The food and service at this restaurant were outstanding. Our hostess, Casey, was incredible—she was friendly, humorous, knowledgeable, and very attentive. She suggested the lobster and shrimp, which turned out to be a superb choice. The meal was served hot and was quite satisfying. I strongly recommend this restaurant to anyone seeking a delightful seafood dinner with great service. If you choose to eat here, be sure to ask for Casey; you won't be disappointed!


Edyth
Edyth

NO THANKSwe saw the sign for happy hour and decided to give this place a try.HH drinks were available, but not food. (why?)we ordered from the menu and the food was decent.while there, there were people who did not want to pay their check. the police were called and we witnessed drama the entire time.the manager, Justin remained professional but there was tension a when one of the women's husband came back, he was shouting and we weren't sure what would happen next.I like my drama on TV...


Tynesha
Tynesha

I've visited this restaurant once before while in Staten Island and had a wonderful experience dining in with my husband. However, we ordered takeout last night, and it was a completely different story. The food was very disappointing; it definitely seemed like a different cook was in the kitchen. We ordered two chicken wing combos, and they not only left the seasonings on the side but also forgot the fries for both orders. Additionally, we tried the "Real Catch," and it tasted so bland. I'll be on the lookout for a new seafood spot when I'm in town next. View menu


Kay
Kay

The store manager is very nice! He turned the biggest tv on for my son to watch cartoons on! Love that! Anything family friendly I love especially with extra kindness towards the kids love it! The food is amazing! My mom definitely enjoyed her lobster tail! The area is nice never crowded air conditioning inside as well bathroom is very clean as well I love the scenery of the under water look my son especially loved the pirate soon as u walk in. It’s great for a date it’s great for family it’s great if ur celebrating a birthday honestly it’s great for any occasion! Just go!


Amy
Amy

We weren't even planning to get seafood; we were actually headed for Wingstop when we stumbled upon this restaurant and decided to give it a shot. What a disappointment it turned out to be. While the seafood seemed fresh, there was hardly any sauce. The manager or host assured us that their special sauce was worth trying, so we ordered 3 pounds of crawfish and 2 clusters of snow crab legs to go, which cost us over $80. Sadly, the sauce they touted as the best was far from flavorful—just excessively salty. Plus, there was barely any sauce on the seafood at all. We’re accustomed to our Cajun seafood being generously coated in savory sauce, often with extra on the side for dipping bread. I re...


Millicent
Millicent

My family and I went out to eat here and the experience was horrific. The food was just terrible.. From the appetizers to the main dishes we ordered. The menu was pretty limited and pricey for what they were offering. I ordered crab fries and it was topped with initiation crab meat. Being that this is a seafood restaurant I didn't think they would even sell fake crab. It was definitely not worth the price. The lobster bisque was cold and extremely thick.... The seafood rice was just ok.. I wouldn't order it again. After the appetizers I really wanted to cancel my dinner order. The best thing I had was the watermelon margarita. There were only 2 people working upfront.. the manager and the wa... View menu

City of New York

City of New York

New York City is renowned for its diverse culinary scene, featuring classic street foods like hot dogs and pretzels, along with international cuisines from every corner of the globe.

Categories

  • Meat Explore our mouth-watering meat selection, featuring expertly grilled steaks, tender chicken, and flavorful lamb dishes, each seasoned to perfection for an unforgettable dining experience.
  • Fries Crispy, golden fries seasoned to perfection, offering a delightful crunch with every bite. Perfect as a side or snack, these fries come in various styles, from classic to loaded gourmet options. View menu
  • Seafood Dive into the freshest catches of the sea with our seafood selection, featuring exquisite dishes prepared with high-quality fish and shellfish. Savor the flavors of the ocean in every bite!
  • Chicken Succulent and savory, our chicken dishes are crafted with tender meat, flavorful seasonings, and diverse culinary inspirations. Enjoy a delectable variety that's sure to satisfy every palate.

Amenities

  • Takeout
  • Full Bar
  • menu
  • Television
  • menu
  • Outdoor Seating

Similar Restaurants