Italian Cowboy Cafe

502 3rd Ave, Sheldon, USA, United States

🛍 Cafés, Coffee, Italian, Southern

3.8 💬 131 Reviews

Phone: +17126314222

Address: 502 3rd Ave, Sheldon, USA, United States

City: Sheldon

Menu Dishes: 14

Reviews: 131

"The place was odd to say the very least. The decor itself is that of a bar. Lots of taxidermy and lots of skulls and horns. It also has a little garage sale in the back with not so garage sale prices. The menu, again odd. Don't know what to make of a menu that had egg salad, tuna salad, bologna sandwich, peanut butter and jelly or a BLT. I guess just not what I wanted for lunch. I wanted to try the daily special as it was lasagna day but when the waitress couldn't explain what the gravy is they put on it, I was out. They also make fresh pies for sale. What kind? Who knows. The menu doesn't tell you."

Full menu - 14 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Pasta

Salads

Main Courses

Sandwiches

Beef Dishes

Meat Dishes

Mexican-American Food

Wrap

Blanca Blanca

Is therapy was amazing. Went out to eat there 1st time in a long time and all was it so good.

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Tracy
Tracy

The portions are huge! We had the ribs tonight and they are the best we have ever had! Highly recommend!


Jan
Jan

Ate dinner on 2-5-2022. No menu only buffet. Food was luke warm and not much to choose from. Not good at all.


Kristin
Kristin

We had the ribs and Cowboy brisket nachos. Delicious food and excellent service! We will definitely go back to try more things! If you have not been there...TRY IT!!! View menu


Cortney
Cortney

I have always been pleased with everything on their menu. However, I especially love the flatbreads (all varieties) and the seafood pasta! My friends and I visit this place weekly for our girls' night out!


Karla
Karla

The Alfredo pasta was excellent, and the portion size was generous. I ordered a side salad and some bread as well, and I plan to take some leftovers home. It was nice and quiet during our visit, and the staff were fantastic!


Haniel
Haniel

Nice staff and tasty food. The theme was an unexpected mix but they have pasta and country food under one roof. Ciao Y 'all in deed. I was pleasantly surprised by their buffet option. The (red velvet?)cake was really good and milk is recommended. P View menu


Bianca
Bianca

I stopped by for lunch and was really impressed with the variety on their menu. I ordered a flatbread, which was delicious! The atmosphere is inviting and modern. They also offer a wide selection of alcoholic beverages. Additionally, I noticed a lot of weekly specials, which was a nice touch. The service was excellent as well. I highly recommend this place!


Adrianne
Adrianne

We decided to give breakfast a shot since we had dinner there when they first opened. Unfortunately, the food was even worse than our previous visit, which was already disappointing. The atmosphere felt quite cluttered and made it difficult to relax, even though we were the only customers at the time. Additionally, we didn't feel that the general store vibe fit well with the restaurant experience.


scott
scott

The place was odd to say the very least. The decor itself is that of a bar. Lots of taxidermy and lots of skulls and horns. It also has a little garage sale in the back with not so garage sale prices. The menu, again odd. Don't know what to make of a menu that had egg salad, tuna salad, bologna sandwich, peanut butter and jelly or a BLT. I guess just not what I wanted for lunch. I wanted to try the daily special as it was lasagna day but when the waitress couldn't explain what the gravy is they put on it, I was out. They also make fresh pies for sale. What kind? Who knows. The menu doesn't tell you. View menu

Categories

  • Cafés Charming cafés offering a variety of freshly brewed coffees and teas, along with light snacks, pastries, and desserts. Perfect for a morning pick-me-up or an afternoon treat in a cozy atmosphere.
  • Coffee Indulge in our rich and aromatic coffee selection, expertly brewed to awaken your senses. From classic espresso to creamy lattes, discover the perfect blend to start your day on a flavorful note. View menu
  • Italian Savor the rich and diverse flavors of Italy with our menu, offering classic pasta, savory risottos, and traditional meat and seafood dishes, all crafted with authentic ingredients and passion. Buon appetito!
  • Southern A taste of the South featuring comforting classics like fried chicken, creamy grits, and savory collard greens. Indulge in authentic flavors of traditional Southern cooking with a modern twist.

Amenities

  • Wifi
  • Takeout
  • menu
  • Delivery
  • menu
  • Television

Similar Restaurants