Kill Buck Inn - Menu

4900 Route 36, Canisteo, NY, 14823, United States

🛍 Pizza, Seafood, American, Steakhouse

4.7 💬 313 Reviews
Kill Buck Inn

Phone: +16076984105

Address: 4900 Route 36, Canisteo, NY, 14823, United States

City: Canisteo

Menu Dishes: 29

Reviews: 313

"I really am not sure what to say here.. some of the food was excellent, some not at all... we ordered a burger, well done with fries and a 16oz ribeye (rare) with a salad and onion rings and an extra small fry... the burger was medium rare at best, they steak was medium rare, but somehow burnt on one half of the outside... I'm not talking charbroiled I'm talking it left burnt dust on the plate, almost like the grill was dirty or it was over a very hot area of open fire... the half of the steak that wasn't burnt and bitter was excellent... the onion rings that were ordered were really good and a nice portion, fries were also very good! the salad was good, wish it had more then the 1 slice of cucumber and half a slice of tomato... cucumber and tomato are not really that expensive are they? With a few more peices of each that salad would have been very good!Then let's chat about the waitress... to say that she was inattentive to our table is a gross understatement. She did come back a couple times, once to bring drinks, and once to ask about the food, and the third time when she finally realized drinks were in desperate need if refilling, one completely empty for well over 5 minutes, she was literally for a second then gone again, it took us quite some time to get a refill on our drink... watching her at her other tables, she was very attentive, joking and socializing... was there a reason we got subpar service? Was it because my husband had just gotten out of work when we met there, and hadn't had time to clean up? Were we thought to be less then for that reason? Or was it because we were not regulars? One can only guess, but it should be kept in mind that folk like us understand the value of hard work and being well looked after when we have time to go out and enjoy ourselves, after a hard dirty day at work!The bill was very reasonable for the items ordered, around the $50 mark and the tip usually would have been between 35 and 40% on a bill like this, because we believe in taking care of the folks that take care of us, and feel that the tip should reflect that... that was not the case, so the tip did reflect that so we only tipped 12%...The restaurant dinning area was clean and looked well taken care of, we cannot speak to the bar or the rest rooms as we did not go in there.All and all, we probably would not go back in there, and that is very disappointing... had things been better, this could have been the new date night location we have been looking for..."

Full menu - 29 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Entrées

Burger

Seafood

Sandwiches

Chicken Wings

Chinese - Beef

American Food

Ribs

Sides

Fingerfood

Burgers & Such

Steaks

Salads

Chicken

Hamburgers

Chicken Dishes

Main Course

Grab N' Go

Hamburguesas

Julie Julie

Excellent prime rib best in the area Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Theresa
Theresa

Always great food and consistency. Fantastic service. Love hometown businesses!


Macayla
Macayla

Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Food: 4 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 4 Recommended dishes: Killbuck Pie


Jim
Jim

This is a typical bar and restaurant you’d expect to find in the area. The portion sizes of the food were good for the price, and the wait staff was attentive and friendly. View menu


Brenda
Brenda

I waited over an hour for my food after placing my order. I confirmed the wait time with my dining companion, and we both agree it was definitely an hour. There’s no need for drama here; I’m just stating the facts without any unnecessary insults.


Michael
Michael

I dined in for dinner and found the prices to be very reasonable, ranging from $10 to $20 per person. The service was outstanding, earning a perfect 5, just like the inviting atmosphere. I highly recommend trying the chicken wings; they were a standout dish!


Robert
Robert

I visited for the Prime Rib on Saturday night. The owner was at the bar, making sure to sanitize and clean the tables, and the restaurant was filled with patrons. It was a pleasant dinner in a welcoming atmosphere where I felt right at home. I also ordered a shrimp cocktail, which was both beautiful and delicious! View menu


alena
alena

**Meal Type:** Dinner **Price Per Person:** $100+ **Food Rating:** 5/5 **Service Rating:** 5/5 **Atmosphere Rating:** 5/5 I highly recommend trying the Chicken Wings, Shrimp Cocktail, and Killbuck Pie. Each dish was exceptional, and the service was top-notch. The atmosphere of the restaurant was inviting and enjoyable, making for a perfect dining experience.


Danielle
Danielle

The onion rings, however, were fantastic and came in a generous portion. The fries were also quite good! The salad was decent, but it would have been much better with more than just one slice of cucumber and half a slice of tomato. These ingredients aren't particularly costly, so adding a few more pieces would have made a real difference. Now, let's discuss the service. To say that our waitress was inattentive would be an understatement. She checked on us a couple of times: once to bring drinks, again to ask about the food, and it took her a noticeably long time to refill our drinks—one was completely empty for over five minutes. When she finally noticed, she was there for just a moment bef...


Danielle
Danielle

I really am not sure what to say here.. some of the food was excellent, some not at all... we ordered a burger, well done with fries and a 16oz ribeye (rare) with a salad and onion rings and an extra small fry... the burger was medium rare at best, they steak was medium rare, but somehow burnt on one half of the outside... I'm not talking charbroiled I'm talking it left burnt dust on the plate, almost like the grill was dirty or it was over a very hot area of open fire... the half of the steak that wasn't burnt and bitter was excellent... the onion rings that were ordered were really good and a nice portion, fries were also very good! the salad was good, wish it had more then the 1 slice of... View menu

Categories

  • Pizza Delve into our perfectly baked pizzas, crafted with hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and a blend of gourmet cheeses. Each slice bursts with fresh toppings, ensuring a delightful bite every time.
  • Seafood Dive into the freshest catches of the sea with our seafood selection, featuring exquisite dishes prepared with high-quality fish and shellfish. Savor the flavors of the ocean in every bite! View menu
  • American Enjoy classic American flavors with our diverse menu, featuring juicy burgers, crispy fried chicken, hearty BBQ ribs, and fresh salads. Indulge in timeless comfort with each bite, crafted to satisfy all tastes.
  • Steakhouse Enjoy prime cuts of tender, juicy steaks cooked to perfection, served with classic sides. Indulge in rich flavors and savory seasonings that make each bite an unforgettable experience. Perfect for steak lovers.

Amenities

  • Wifi
  • Takeout
  • menu
  • Delivery
  • menu
  • Parking Area

Similar Restaurants