Lucy's Pizza - Menu

Terrible Sicilian pizza. Dry, over burnt, and hardly any cheese.

Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $1–10 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Stick

This fantastic pizza shop has been a beloved part of the Ossining community for decades, dating back to my childhood in the area. View menu

If you're coming from NYC, this place serves pizza that's reminiscent of the city, and honestly, it’s even better than some I've tried. I highly recommend it!

Are you dying for a piece of real New York City pizza? This is the place. The thin crust, the grease dripping down your hands. It's been such a long time since I've had to blot my pizza with napkins! This is the best pizza I have had in years! 10 stars!!! Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner

Meal Type: Lunch Price Range: $1–10 Food: ★★★★★ Service: ★★★★★ Atmosphere: ★★★★★ I highly recommend this restaurant for lunch! The cheese pizza is a must-try, and the pepperoni sticks are delicious as well. Both dishes were outstanding, earning top marks for their flavor. The service was exceptional, with friendly staff who were attentive and fast. Plus, the atmosphere is inviting and pleasant, making it a great spot for a casual meal. Overall, I had a fantastic experience! View menu

Lucy's is Ossining Village's best Italian food all the food is fresh, tastes flavorful comes out piping hot! I love the chicken cacciatore chicken with red sauce, peppers, onions, mushrooms the penna alla vodka!! Pizza is very good too! Real deal NYC style pizza. Service is consistently friendly. The atmosphere is nice enough to want to sit down eat. It's on a really picturesque corner, in a beautiful historic building overlooking Downtown Ossining, across from the beautiful, historic Baptist Church Ossining High School. Definitely an Ossining institution.

I ordered a large paprika and cheese sticks. The cheese sticks were crispy and flavorful, with a generous portion and plenty of marinara sauce. The pizza is classic NYC style: chewy, thin, and easy to fold. The sauce is tangy and well-balanced, just like the paprika. Despite ordering for delivery, the pizza arrived hot and fresh, and my cheese sticks remained crunchy. My only complaint is that they don’t have a website, which means you can't order online. I literally had no idea how much I was spending until the end. Seriously, it’s 2022—get a website! I've deducted a star for the ordering process, but that shouldn't reflect on the food itself. This is definitely the best pizza in Ossining.

This is my favorite pizzeria in Ossining. I really love pizza and have several go-to spots, but this one stands out as one of my top choices. During the school year, it can get quite busy around lunchtime because many high school students come here. However, they do a great job ensuring that the line moves quickly, so you won't be waiting long. The staff is incredibly friendly; the more you visit, the more they remember you and make you feel like family. I've had their pizza on numerous occasions, and it's always been excellent. I've also tried their salads, and they were delicious too. The interior is reasonably sized with a few tables where you can sit and enjoy your meal in peace. Plus, i... View menu