Phone: +16464846200
Address: New York, NY 10024, 421 Amsterdam Ave, United States, Broad Channel
City: Broad Channel
Menu Dishes: 29
Reviews: 339
Website: https://www.madeinnewyorkpizza.com/
"This is one of those places that’s definitely worth visiting if you’re in the area. However, being from Brooklyn, I only get to try it when I’m nearby, which doesn’t really give me a chance to fully appreciate it. I’m planning to give it another shot. The issue isn’t with the taste; it’s the location. I gave it 4 stars because it’s my fault, not theirs. The pizza was great the first time, but I missed the mark the second time. I’ll update my review after the third visit. - PizzaQueen."
Full menu - 29 options
All prices are estimates on menu.
Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Classic cheese pizza featuring a rich tomato sauce, gooey mozzarella, and fresh basil on a crisp, golden crust.
Pepperoni Pizza
Classic pepperoni pizza with zesty tomato sauce and a generous layer of melted mozzarella cheese on a crisp crust.
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Spicy Buffalo sauce, grilled chicken, mozzarella, and a hint of ranch on a crispy pizza base.
Pizza Squares
Dessert
Specialty Pizza
Extra Sauces
Sides
Garlic Knots
Soft, warm dough knots infused with garlic and herbs, served with marinara dipping sauce.
Chicken
Buffalo Chicken
Spicy fried chicken tossed in buffalo sauce, served with celery sticks and blue cheese dressing.
Desserts
Round Pies
Salads
Soup &Amp; Sauce
Pizza Specialties
Knots
N
Perfect crust EVERY TIME!!
Address
Reviews
Willa
Great pizza! Friendly staff. Super clean place. I would recommend this place if you’re looking for New York pizza!
Jack
Worst pizza margherita ever. Skimpy sauce and cheese, underbaked and raw-tasting crust. Rude on the phone. Never again!
Pamela
Incredible pizza! We tried the cheese pizza and the square spicy pepperoni pizza. I would definitely order these again! View menu
Adriano
Exactly what I think of when imagining the perfect new york slice. Got the vodka sauce and pep square. Crust is perfect and flavour is all there
Tiffany
Great selection of slices. Served quickly and in a friendly manner. The staff is kind and accommodating. The pizza looks delicious and I trust that it will be, God willing.
Chelsea
This is the best pizza I've ever had! The buffalo chicken pizza had the perfect amount of buffalo flavor, and it was served at just the right temperature, even though it was cold outside. The price was excellent too. There was plenty of seating available. Highly recommend! View menu
Eileen
Awful place. Don't come here. They are so nasty. They got my order wrong. I returned it nicely and they told me you ordered that. I told them no I ordered two of the same. Plus my roll was burned and they said that's how they come. No horrible horrible service. The only nice one was a cashier
Michele
Got a couple of pies from this place to go. The customer service was pretty good and the pies delicious. Ordered buff chick, cheese, pepperoni, spinach, and grandmas (Sicilian- only 8 slices). All the pizzas were delicious, and I loved them. My only disclaimer is I wasn't expecting the Sicilian to be so small but other than that tons of food to feed 20ish adults. We all really enjoyed- shout out to buff chick pizza which I think was my favorite. Overall cute place and good food!
Crystal
This is one of those places that’s definitely worth visiting if you’re in the area. However, being from Brooklyn, I only get to try it when I’m nearby, which doesn’t really give me a chance to fully appreciate it. I’m planning to give it another shot. The issue isn’t with the taste; it’s the location. I gave it 4 stars because it’s my fault, not theirs. The pizza was great the first time, but I missed the mark the second time. I’ll update my review after the third visit. - PizzaQueen. View menu
Broad Channel
Broad Channel is a small island community in Queens, known for its seafood. Locals enjoy fresh clams and fish, often prepared in simple, home-style recipes typical of the area.
Categories
-
Bars Discover our selection of expertly crafted cocktails, refreshing beers, and our curated list of fine wines. Perfect for unwinding with friends or pairing with your favorite dishes from our menu. Cheers!
-
Pizza Delve into our perfectly baked pizzas, crafted with hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and a blend of gourmet cheeses. Each slice bursts with fresh toppings, ensuring a delightful bite every time. View menu
-
And Grill Grilled to perfection, offering a selection of juicy meats, fresh seafood, and flavorful veggies, all charred with savory spices. Perfect for those seeking a hearty and satisfying meal with smoky undertones.
-
American Cuisine American cuisine offers a diverse menu featuring hearty classics like burgers, fried chicken, and BBQ alongside vibrant salads, indulgent desserts, and innovative twists on traditional favorites.
Amenities
-
Wine
-
Beer
- menu
-
Outdoor
- menu
