Mr Gyro's - Menu

5358 W 38th St, Indianapolis, Indiana, 46254, United States

🛍 Greek, Casual, American, North American

4.2 💬 3723 Reviews
Mr Gyro's

Phone: +13173889788

Address: 5358 W 38th St, Indianapolis, Indiana, 46254, United States

City: Indianapolis

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 3723

"My family and I typically go through the drive-thru when we visit, and this time we ordered 3 cheeseburgers, 1 double cheeseburger, 1 onion ring, and 1 large fry. There were two cars ahead of us, and we were prepared to wait since we know the food is made to order. The other two cars received their orders in a reasonable amount of time, but we just kept sitting there with no food. After 16 minutes, my husband decided to back up to the window after noticing that the two cars behind us had been served. When we looked inside, they were finally packing our order. After a total wait of 24 minutes, we finally received our food. Unfortunately, once we got home, the taste of the burgers and onion rings was just average. The kids thought the fries were a bit better than average. Overall, I can’t shake the feeling that they forgot about us. It’s frustrating to wait 24 minutes for average burgers, fries, and onion rings at a fast food restaurant. I left feeling disappointed."

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Entrées

Side Orders

Chicken

Salads

Sandwiches

Uncategorized

Gyros

Chicken Wings

American Food

Cold Subs

Fish And Seafood Dishes

Dessert

Family Sized Orders (Order At Least 1 Hour Ahead)

Wings

Burgers & Hot Dogs

Indian

Burger

Fried Potatoes

Rib Specials

Salads And Chili

Appetizers

Appetizer

Chicken Dishes

Deep Fried Nuggets

Saunseri Saunseri

Still my favorite gyro place around. Out of the way for me now I live in Brownsburg. Price went up considerably in past few years which is good. Too out of the way for me and the increased price lets me let go easier..Food: 4/5

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Carlisa
Carlisa

Food is good mainly the fried chicken wings with lemon pepper seasoning and they ok my request for all flats. And barbeque sauce on the fries.. The men are very polite.. The women polite but to eager to rush you to give order.Food: 5/5


User
User

The best Gyro place in town! We love coming to Mr. Gyro, it?s a nice family owned restaurant with a wide range of options. The owners are very nice and friendly to us every-time we come here. Thank you so much for the amazing food and wonderful service!


Danica
Danica

Food was good as usual! However they have changed the menu like they used to have a cold roast beef sub with chips for 5.99. But they don't offer that and now the subs range from 8$-10$ dollars. Overall I still like them they've just changed slightlyFood: 4/5 View menu


Jennifer
Jennifer

I used to enjoy this place back in the day. In my recent experience, the food was not tasty like it used to be. My Gyro was very bland, and the meat was dry. The sauce was bland. Not sure that I will go back. Waste of money. Nice, friendly atmosphere though.Food: 3/5


Desiree
Desiree

I have lived in Indy for years and had never tried it. I wish I had tried it sooner! I got a crispy chicken salad, which was very fresh and had a lot of chicken. My family got a variety including the chicken over rice. Delicious! All of it. A new favorite for.my family!


Sarah
Sarah

This place was a nice spot for dinner. The staff was super friendly and service was fast. Only thing I had a slight issue with was the gyro meat seemed a little dry, they don't use the tziki sauce and overload the onions a bit, dining area could have used some cleaning. Otherwise, nice quantity of food, nice atmosphere and worth the money! View menu


User
User

This restaurant offers great prices, tasty food, and a lovely local atmosphere. I especially enjoyed the fried sides like okra and mushrooms—they're particularly delicious! I've visited several times and there was only one dish that didn't impress me, which was the Italian sausages. Overall, you can feed a family of four for under $40, making it a fantastic deal!


adrienne
adrienne

The food is good but it’s definitely changed since the last time I was here. I’ve always gotten the Philly steak and cheese sandwich and it’s usually a good amount. Today when I went the first thing I noticed was how light the box was. I opened it and saw the sandwich looked child size. It tasted ok but not quite the same. I wonder if the change is because of cost. Either way I’ll go back again because I’ve been supporting them since 1999.


B
B

My family and I typically go through the drive-thru when we visit, and this time we ordered 3 cheeseburgers, 1 double cheeseburger, 1 onion ring, and 1 large fry. There were two cars ahead of us, and we were prepared to wait since we know the food is made to order. The other two cars received their orders in a reasonable amount of time, but we just kept sitting there with no food. After 16 minutes, my husband decided to back up to the window after noticing that the two cars behind us had been served. When we looked inside, they were finally packing our order. After a total wait of 24 minutes, we finally received our food. Unfortunately, once we got home, the taste of the burgers and onion ri... View menu

Indianapolis

Indianapolis

Indianapolis, known for the Indy 500, offers Midwestern comfort food, with staples like pork tenderloin sandwiches and sugar cream pie, reflecting its rich cultural and culinary heritage.

Categories

  • Greek Savor the rich flavors of Greece with our authentic selection of traditional dishes. Delight in fresh ingredients, aromatic herbs, and classic recipes that bring the essence of the Mediterranean to your table.
  • Casual Our Casual menu offers delicious comfort food for effortless dining. From juicy burgers and scrumptious sandwiches to fresh salads and hearty mains, our diverse selection provides a delightful experience for any casual outing. View menu
  • American Enjoy classic American flavors with our diverse menu, featuring juicy burgers, crispy fried chicken, hearty BBQ ribs, and fresh salads. Indulge in timeless comfort with each bite, crafted to satisfy all tastes.
  • North American Savor the diverse flavors of North America with dishes ranging from juicy burgers and crispy fried chicken to tangy BBQ ribs and fresh salads, all capturing the essence of regional favorites and comfort classics.

Amenities

  • Wifi
  • Credit
  • menu
  • Takeout
  • menu
  • Delivery

Similar Restaurants

Ali'i Poke

Ali'i Poke

910 W 10th St Ste 4, Indianapolis, IN 46202, United States

Menu • Poke • Pizza • Sushi • Fusion


"My husband and I went here for lunch. I was pregnant, had gestational diabetes, and a craving for sushi. We didn 't know what it was going in but the woman behind the counter was super sweet explaining it (deconstructed sushi) and patient as she explained our options. The bowls seemed a little expensive so my husband and I both got the medium size. He got rice and I had salad greens. There were tons of options to choose from and I want to go back now that I can eat the fish! I was able to have the spicy crab mix and all the fruit and veggie choices. They did have a cooked seafood option, but I didn 't feel like looking up if it was baby safe. The miso soup was good too! FILLING for the price. I would not have been able to finish if I got rice and my husband said he was stuffed; but we both finished! Next time we go, we 're planning to split the large one to keep ourselves from eating to much! Great food, friendly and knowledgeable staff, and clean restaurant. If we hadn 't walked from my husband 's working parking may have been an issue, but that 's the same for every place in that strip mall. Got food again. My husband and I split the large. We also got the mango sweet coconut rice to try. It was good, but not my thing. I recommend at least trying it once. I would eat it again vit not necessarily order it on my own. We also tried the honey wasabi on the side of our meal. It wasn 't what I was expecting. It was sweeter and creamier. Still enjoyed this place and love that he and I can split a large and be full!"