New City Cafe - Menu

124 N 4th St, Lake Mary I-32746-2930, United States

🛍 Tea, Cafés, Coffee, Fast Food

4.6 💬 792 Reviews
New City Cafe

Phone: (+1)4079157075

Address: 124 N 4th St, Lake Mary I-32746-2930, United States

City: Lake Mary

Menu Dishes: 12

Reviews: 792

Website: https://www.newcitycoffeeco.com/

"I had previously ordered the George Special and it was fantastic! So, I decided to give it another try, but this time it was disappointing. The avocado was brown, the toast was slightly burnt, and the whole dish seemed hastily put together. I’m willing to give them another chance since my first order was clearly made with care, while this second one felt rushed, as if they were eager to clock out for the day. I wasn’t pleased, especially given the high delivery charges. Even the coffee wasn’t up to the standard of my first experience."

Full menu - 12 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Toast

Bakery

Egg Dishes

Indian

Viennoiseries

Bagels, Rolls, And Other Baked Goods

Breakfast Mood

Dessert

Blended Drinks

Fruit Ice-Cream Smoothies

Marisol Marisol

Food was very tasty as well as the coffee awesome atmosphere too

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Jessica
Jessica

Absolutely the best coffee in town, and the staff is incredibly friendly!


Brian
Brian

The coffee and sandwiches were excellent. The staff was friendly and accommodating!


Chris
Chris

Every dish I've tried here has been outstanding. I'm particularly fond of the breakfast burrito. View menu


Gigi
Gigi

This is a wonderful spot to unwind and savor a delightful cup of coffee. I really enjoy the pastries here...


Carolina
Carolina

Absolutely delicious!!! The best coffee I've ever had. From the moment I walked through the door, I felt right at home.


Shari
Shari

The cappuccino was excellent—stylish and paired nicely with a plain croissant, which was also good. I will definitely return for a crepe and another coffee. View menu


Lynette
Lynette

New City Coffee Co. in Lake Mary is a must-visit! They have the most delicious-looking pastries. Cakes, danish, fritters, macaroons. They serve breakfast foods and of course Coffee, Tea, and Smoothies.


Maureen
Maureen

Since my first visit, I've become addicted to their veggie omelette. It's cooked precisely as I request, and it's delicious. The staff is very friendly and works efficiently. I'm so glad we have this little gem right in downtown Lake Mary. I'm now a regular!


Amanda
Amanda

I had previously ordered the George Special and it was fantastic! So, I decided to give it another try, but this time it was disappointing. The avocado was brown, the toast was slightly burnt, and the whole dish seemed hastily put together. I’m willing to give them another chance since my first order was clearly made with care, while this second one felt rushed, as if they were eager to clock out for the day. I wasn’t pleased, especially given the high delivery charges. Even the coffee wasn’t up to the standard of my first experience. View menu

Categories

  • Tea Explore our selection of soothing teas, offering both classic and exotic blends. Perfectly brewed to awaken your senses, indulge in our range for a moment of tranquility and flavor in every sip.
  • Cafés Charming cafés offering a variety of freshly brewed coffees and teas, along with light snacks, pastries, and desserts. Perfect for a morning pick-me-up or an afternoon treat in a cozy atmosphere. View menu
  • Coffee Savor our selection of expertly crafted coffees, from rich espressos to creamy cappuccinos. Whether you need a morning boost or a leisurely sip, our coffee options promise warmth and comfort in every cup.
  • Fast Food Enjoy a variety of quick and delicious meals perfect for on-the-go dining. From juicy burgers and crispy fries to refreshing drinks, our fast food menu satisfies your cravings with speedy service and irresistible flavors.

Similar Restaurants

Ruth's Chris Steak House Lake Mary

Ruth's Chris Steak House Lake Mary

80 Colonial Center ParkwayFL 32746, Lake Mary, United States

Menu • Steak • Seafood • Steakhouse • Bar-lounge


"So I believe in honesty...Heres the deal...Went there on a Sunday night...Had a pretty good crowd. Ordered large filets for the guys and petite for the woman..al came at the same time..Ordered mashed potatoes and creamed spinach...NO serving spoon with spinach was first issue..guys filets great..womans filets tough as rubber...waitress hard to find..called a buster over sent first one back..he said he would have replaced with a large one they are better, other woman tried to eat hers..rubber...sent it back within minute of first..different one came back in record time..very one came back minutes later and tough as nails... COME ON..This is a steak house.. you mean to tell me that you couldn't take another medium rare filet and get it out right away? still no serving spoon, now have asked twice... again saw another busier asked for serving spoon...finally got it...so, by the time the serving spoon came and we got the filet back the rest of us who were trying to be nice had cold filet...I eat at the one in Pittsburgh frequently....I go for the sizzle...not a cold filet...asked to see manager...she comped the woman filet and bought a desert...I really dont want a free filet...I want what I came for...a great filet and great serving experience...They certainly missed their mark on this one....sorry, but I call it as I see it...would NOT recommend"