Phone: +18134434598
Address: 10434 N Dale Mabry Hwy, 33618, Tampa, United States
City: Tampa
Menu Dishes: 35
Reviews: 4353
Website: http://nynypizzeria.com/
"I ordered from this restaurant on UberEats and had to check it out myself because the pizza was absolutely delicious! It's the best pizza I've had in Tampa, and I eat a lot of pizza! Where has this pizza been all my life?! I will definitely be ordering again. The pizza features a large New York-style thin crust with a crispy, light, and airy edge. The sauce tastes homemade, made from fresh tomatoes and garlic. It's absolutely amazing! I'm hooked—I ate everything and I want more!"
Full menu - 35 options
All prices are estimates on menu.
Salads
Chef Salad
A fresh and crisp salad with mixed greens, turkey, ham, cheese, eggs, and vegetables, dressed lightly to perfection.
Greek Salad
Fresh tomatoes, cucumbers, olives, feta cheese, and red onions, tossed with olive oil and oregano.
Caesar Salad
Crisp romaine lettuce tossed with creamy Caesar dressing, Parmesan cheese, and crunchy croutons.
Garden Salad
Fresh mixed greens with tomatoes, cucumbers, carrots, and your choice of dressing.
Buffalo Salad
Crispy buffalo chicken on fresh greens, topped with blue cheese, tomatoes, and zesty buffalo ranch dressing.
Antipasto Salad
A vibrant mix of fresh greens, cured meats, cheeses, olives, and Italian dressing.
Pasta
Manicotti
Manicotti: Tube-shaped pasta filled with soft ricotta cheese, topped with marinara sauce and melted mozzarella, baked to perfection.
Lasagna Pasta
Layers of pasta with cheese, rich meat sauce, and creamy béchamel, baked to golden perfection.
Pizza
Chicken Wings
Wings
Crispy chicken wings tossed in your choice of tangy or spicy sauce.
Baked
Lasagna
Layers of pasta, rich meat sauce, creamy béchamel, and melted cheese baked to perfection.
Calzone
Calzone
A folded pizza filled with cheese, tomato sauce, and a variety of meats or vegetables, baked until golden.
Dessert
Cannoli
Crispy pastry shells filled with sweet, creamy ricotta cheese and dusted with powdered sugar.
Side Dishes
Wings
Boneless
Savory and tender boneless chicken served with a side of tangy dipping sauce.
Meat Dishes
Meatballs
Juicy meatballs simmered in rich tomato sauce with herbs, served with crusty bread for a hearty meal.
Al Forno*
Baked Ziti
Baked ziti with ricotta, mozzarella, and tomato sauce, oven-baked to perfection for a cheesy and savory Italian delight.
Specialty Pies
Popular Products
Steaks
Steak Salad
Grilled steak slices on a bed of mixed greens with cherry tomatoes, red onions, and a balsamic vinaigrette drizzle.
Side Orders
Can Of Soda
A chilled can of your favorite fizzy soda to refresh and quench your thirst.
Sides
Garlic Knots
Soft, warm dough knots infused with garlic and herbs, served with marinara dipping sauce.
Entrées
Garlic Bread
Toasted bread topped with garlic butter and herbs, perfect as a savory appetizer or side.
Extras
Fried Mushroom
Crispy fried mushrooms with a golden batter, served with a zesty dipping sauce for a savory snack.
Kids Menu
Marinara Pasta
Classic Italian pasta with savory tomato sauce, garlic, and herbs.
Seafood
Stuffed Shells
Pasta shells filled with ricotta, garlic, and herbs, baked in savory marinara sauce, topped with melted mozzarella.
Desserts
Chocolate Cake
Rich and moist chocolate cake layered with creamy chocolate frosting for the ultimate indulgence.
Futomaki Rolls
Salad Dressing
Chicken Dishes
Chicken Tenders
Crispy golden chicken tenders served with your choice of dipping sauce.
Chicken
Buffalo Chicken
Spicy fried chicken tossed in buffalo sauce, served with celery sticks and blue cheese dressing.
Kevin
The staff were particularly friendly towards my younger siblings, which made our visit even more delightful. I will definitely be returning!
Address
Reviews
User
Perfect local pizza!! Great taste and crunchy crust. It is also worth noting that the slices are HUGE just like NY. I am from NY so you know this review is LEGIT!
User
New York New York Pizza is fantastic! We ordered a large cheese pizza and buffalo wings, and both were delicious. Since my first day in Tampa, I've been coming back for more, and it has never disappointed me.
User
We ordered a medium supreme pizza, but what we got looked more like a leftover pepperoni pizza with a few toppings thrown on top. It would take a lot to convince me that this supreme pizza was actually baked in an oven. With so many other choices in town, who would spend $18.99 on this? View menu
Tammy
I had an amazing experience with the Supreme and Four Cheese pizzas! The toppings were fresh and plentiful, and the crust was reminiscent of true New York-style—crispy with just the right amount of flop. Definitely a 5-star dish! I also sampled the cheese fries; they had a generous amount of cheese, but while they were seasoned well, they weren't crispy. I’d rate them 3 stars.
Doctor
I ordered the pizza, wings, and knots special for $21.99, but was charged $32 instead. They also forgot which pizza I had ordered, which can happen, I understand that. When we mentioned that we would be dining in, they brought everything over in to-go boxes and said to have a good night. It felt like they were hinting that we weren't welcome after that. Rating for the food: 3/5.
Mona
I only order pizza from your restaurant, but I was really let down by the cannoli. For $6.00, I expected it to be filled with ricotta cheese, but there was only about a teaspoon of cheese at each end. That's quite disappointing. As for the garlic knots, they were not actually knots at all; they were just bread rolls with some olive oil and cheese on top. Not impressed. Overall, I would rate the food 3 out of 5. View menu
User
Absolutely fantastic! I love the thin, crispy crust that’s almost slightly charred. It definitely brings back memories of NJ/NY style pizza. The staff are friendly, the kitchen operates quickly, and they actually pay attention to Toast orders! I’ve experienced many instances of forgotten dressings or sides at other places, but NYNY Pizza got everything spot on. Also, don’t miss out on the garlic knots—they're incredible!
User
They are always consistent, and I usually order the same pizza every time, haha. Even when I call in and ask them to spread the pepperoni more evenly, they make sure to do it! Their thin crust is perfectly thin, just the way I like it. I even tried a salad once, and it was fresh and tasty. The ingredients were definitely not old, which is a big plus. Keep up the great consistency! It really matters and makes all the difference.
User
I ordered from this restaurant on UberEats and had to check it out myself because the pizza was absolutely delicious! It's the best pizza I've had in Tampa, and I eat a lot of pizza! Where has this pizza been all my life?! I will definitely be ordering again. The pizza features a large New York-style thin crust with a crispy, light, and airy edge. The sauce tastes homemade, made from fresh tomatoes and garlic. It's absolutely amazing! I'm hooked—I ate everything and I want more! View menu
Categories
-
Pizza Delve into our perfectly baked pizzas, crafted with hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and a blend of gourmet cheeses. Each slice bursts with fresh toppings, ensuring a delightful bite every time.
-
Salads Fresh and vibrant, our salads are crafted with seasonal ingredients and a mix of crisp greens, colorful vegetables, and unique dressings, offering a delicious and healthy choice for any palate. View menu
-
Italian Savor the rich and diverse flavors of Italy with our menu, offering classic pasta, savory risottos, and traditional meat and seafood dishes, all crafted with authentic ingredients and passion. Buon appetito!
-
Catering Catering services offering a diverse range of delicious and beautifully presented dishes, perfect for any event or gathering. Our menu combines creativity with quality ingredients to delight your guests.
Amenities
-
Takeout
-
Delivery
- menu
-
Television
- menu
-
Accepts Credit Cards
