New York Pizzeria - Menu

Very nice and clean. Nice staff and they made our pizza to eat in fast. Excellent pie!!

As an Italian who has eaten (and made) enough pizza to have traces of sauce in my bloodstream, I can confidently say that this is the best pizza in all of upstate New York.

Best in town any town around Friendly folks. A little pricey, some people can't afford but would buy if they were able. It is what it is. Overall this store is a true thumbs up. AAAA View menu

The restaurant is closed, and I tried calling five times in one day with no answer. Their website says they’re open, but they are not. Service: Takeout Meal type: Dinner Service rating: 1

Pizza was excellent and great service. On vacation from orange county, ny and was looking for a good pizza place. Read a few reviews that said the pizza was good and definatly did not disappoint ?

We really love the cheese blend and sauce on this pizza; it's slightly better than our other favorites. We'll go out of our way to visit this place, which is unusual for us. There's plenty of street parking available, and it's easy to reach. We haven't tried any of the other menu items yet, but we plan to come back for dinner. They offer a great variety of food, and the prices are quite reasonable too. View menu

"The pizza here is absolutely delicious—so much so that we ordered it two days in a row! The staff is very friendly, and we enjoyed the dine-in experience for lunch. The price per person was between $10 and $20. I would rate the food a solid 5, the service a perfect 5, and the atmosphere also a 5. I highly recommend trying the Garlic Knots with Marinara Sauce, the Garlic Broccoli Pizza, and the Sicilian Pizza with two toppings."

It's hard to believe, but it's true! Some of the very best pizza I've ever had in my 55 years of life, in Ft Plain , NY! I often drive 45 min to to get to this place, passing many pizza places along the way. It's that good. I do a lot of reviews but rarely make recommendations, but I simply must strongly recommend that you try it if you have a chance. When you add to the quality of the food the super friendly staff and great service, what you end up with is 5 well-earned stars.

Absolutely fantastic! New York Pizza has truly mastered the art of crafting mouthwatering slices. From the generous toppings to the perfect blend of cheeses, every bite is a delightful explosion of flavor. The crust strikes the perfect balance between chewy and crispy, transporting me straight to the streets of New York. The impeccable service and speedy delivery only add to the overall excellent experience. If you're searching for authentic, delectable pizza, look no further than New York Pizza! View menu