Nutty Irishman - Menu

323 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735, United States, Syosset

🛍 Pub, Pubs, Grill, Lunch

4.1 💬 3109 Reviews
Nutty Irishman

Phone: +15162939700

Address: 323 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735, United States, Syosset

City: Syosset

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 3109

"After having just one drink each, we decided to leave, but I needed to use the restroom again. As we headed to the back, having no access to the front restroom, security stopped us and informed us that we could not use the bathroom because it was for a private party—even though I had just used it. They then proceeded to escort us out of the bar and into a neighboring bakery that was closed, with all the lights turned off and the chairs stacked on the tables. We were then guided to a restroom tucked away in a corner. After using the bathroom, I requested to speak with a manager because the entire situation was utterly ridiculous. I was told they weren’t sure if the manager was available, even though I knew she was, as it had only been around 25 minutes since my last visit to the restroom. When I finally spoke with the manager, Catherine, she approached me with a smile and laughter, dismissing my concerns as if they were trivial. I explained that it was inappropriate for a male security guard to escort two women out of the bar and into a closed bakery to use the restroom. I was met with laughter and told that I could have turned on the lights, implying there was nothing to fear. This lack of understanding about the dangers women face in such situations is astonishing. When I asked for the contact information for someone above her, I was told it was public knowledge and was once again laughed at. I looked at the security guard and expressed that he should never have been put in that position; it seemed clear he felt pressured by the manager, Catherine. All she had to do was show some empathy for the distressing situation we had just experienced, but instead, she was rude and unprofessional. Once my anger subsided, I felt incredibly saddened. As a strong-willed 31-year-old who wasn’t under the influence of alcohol, I couldn’t help but think about how different this could have been for a more vulnerable individual. With a security guard who had ill intentions, things could have turned out much worse. The establishment needs to do better—not just as a business, but as responsible human beings."

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Sandwiches

Side Dishes

Artisan Egg Sandwiches - Breakfast Menu

Salads

Dessert

“Grown Up ” Grilled Cheese - Lunch Menu

Beverage Menu

Sides

Toast

Main Courses

Breakfasts

Fries

Mains

Specialties

Aunty's Optional Sides

Juice Bar Menu - Protein Shakes

Breakfast Specialties

Chicken

Brunch All Day

Salad

Lunch - Salads

Lunch Paninis

Pancakes And Toasts

Griddled Goods

Wraps Sandwiches & Melts - Lunch Menu

Paninis

Lunch - Add Ons & Extras

Justin Justin

It can get a bit crowded at times, but overall, it's a fantastic place.

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Lynn
Lynn

Tunnel 2 Towers fundraiser was phenomenal! Great music ? great service, bartenders come in 1st place!!


User
User

Absolutely wonderful! The food was fantastic, and the music was great too. The 70s band was excellent!


User
User

This is a great fun place. The bands are awesome that play there. They also have a dance floor and a dj that plays music in between band sets View menu


Mike
Mike

This is a great venue for live music and beverages if you so choose. Polite staff and great sound system/engineer. This night was Crossing Sunrise at work; great band! You should plan a visit!!


Joe
Joe

Never gave a negative review of any live music venue but is me or my favorite cover band that sounded really echo and draining on the stage here? Been following this band for 8 years and never heard them sound this bad.


Seela
Seela

They host line dancing every Tuesday night, with lessons typically starting around 8 PM on nights when there isn't a live band. DJ Neil is fantastic! If you're looking for a great place to line dance, this is the spot for you. View menu


User
User

What an amazing place! Greeted by the kindest servers and we had such a great meal. Everything is house made and the chef, I think her name was Tina, I should have asked again SHE IS AMAZING! It's a beautiful little hidden gem in Farmingdale with breakfast and lunch all day. The bakery display is dangerous, I got almost one of everything to bring home to my family. I will be back and thank you Danielle, your service was 100! ???


Alex
Alex

This place is great. Just walked in for a drink or two, might've been 3. I'm not sure about their food. So I can't comment on that. The beer selection was good. We walked in around 9ish, and a live band was playing on a Saturday night. Music was good, definitely room for dancing. Live DJ afterward. I'm in my 50s, so just a word of caution. Around 11 o'clock, a herd of 20 something yr olds start pouring in. Other than that, good time if you are in the mood to party for a bit.


Gabrielle
Gabrielle

After having just one drink each, we decided to leave, but I needed to use the restroom again. As we headed to the back, having no access to the front restroom, security stopped us and informed us that we could not use the bathroom because it was for a private party—even though I had just used it. They then proceeded to escort us out of the bar and into a neighboring bakery that was closed, with all the lights turned off and the chairs stacked on the tables. We were then guided to a restroom tucked away in a corner. After using the bathroom, I requested to speak with a manager because the entire situation was utterly ridiculous. I was told they weren’t sure if the manager was available, eve... View menu

Categories

  • Pub Enjoy a lively atmosphere with our classic pub favorites. From hearty burgers and fish 'n' chips to savory pies and craft brews, our menu promises a cozy experience ideal for unwinding with friends.
  • Pubs "Discover a cozy atmosphere with hearty meals, craft beers, and classic pub fare. Enjoy comfort food favorites like fish and chips, burgers, and wings, paired with a refreshing pint or creative cocktail." View menu
  • Grill Succulent meats and fresh vegetables perfectly cooked over an open flame, delivering rich smoky flavors. Savor tender steaks, juicy burgers, and tangy marinated kebabs, all grilled to perfection for an unforgettable dining experience.
  • Lunch Satisfy your midday cravings with our delicious lunch menu. From fresh salads and hearty sandwiches to savory soups and vibrant bowls, each dish is crafted to give you the perfect midday boost.

Amenities

  • Takeout
  • Delivery
  • menu
  • Television
  • menu
  • Outdoor Seating

Similar Restaurants

La Parma Ii

La Parma Ii

452 W Jericho Tpke., 11743-6032, Huntington, United States

Menu • Wine • Dining • Italian • Bar-lounge


"just adding to address the response. I do take back that you didn't offer an apology, you did. Sorry. However, our conversation and your response still do not address my chief complaint , which was not that your portion sizes were too large but that the person that picked up the phone should have suggested we had too much food and maybe we should cut back on one or tow portion sizes, especially since I made it clear how unsure I was and was looking for her guidance. That is the crux of my issue. i have been a regular patron for decades, by dining in or in some or in this case ordered in. i asked the receptionist for some guidance for 6 people, telling her we wanted 6-7 dishes. We were 6 people with average appetites and half the food is leftover. i understand that 1.5 orders feeds 4-6 people but what the receptionist should have told me once she knew we were ordering that many dishes we should have ordered less dishes ordered the single size portion in some if not all cases. Case in point, she suggested 2 full size trays of garlic bread (which was horrible btw) and 3/4 of it was left over. I unnecessarily spent an exorbitant amount of money on a 6 person meal, trusted the receptionist and should have received better guidance when ordering that many things. when i called back 2 days later to express my feelings to the manager, he basically offered me a refund for the garlic bread, not taking any responsibility for being totally misguided. LP has been doing this for decades and should KNOW that the more the dishes, cut back on the portion sizes...... Had i received a bit more of a token gesture and a small apology, you wouldn't be reading this review. DG"