Phone: +12124759540
Address: New York, NY 10003, 123 E 18th St, United States, Broad Channel
City: Broad Channel
Menu Dishes: 35
Reviews: 217
Website: https://www.paulandjimmys.com/
"Possibly my worst experience I’ve had at any restaurant ever. Went in with the expecting good food and amazing service like the rest of the reviews here. The food was not only undercooked and under seasoned but the staff gossip with slurs in their language (Spanish) which doesn’t encourage anyone to ask for help or to bring attention to anything that may be wrong. They spend most of their time talking and rarely checking on us. Food was absolutely disappointing. Pasta was undercooked and the tor … – show"
Full menu - 35 options
All prices are estimates on menu.
Dessert
Cannoli
Crispy pastry shells filled with sweet, creamy ricotta cheese and hints of vanilla and chocolate.
Tiramisu
A classic Italian dessert featuring layers of coffee-soaked ladyfingers, rich mascarpone cream, and a dusting of cocoa powder.
Cheesecake
Creamy, rich cheesecake with a buttery graham cracker crust and a smooth, sweet topping.
Pasta
Linguine
Linguine pasta served with a light sauce, garnished with fresh herbs, offering a delightful blend of flavors and textures.
Cannelloni
Tube-shaped pasta filled with cheese and spinach, baked with tomato sauce and topped with melted mozzarella.
Pasta And Beans
Hearty pasta combined with creamy beans in a savory tomato sauce.
Salads
Caprese
Fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, basil, olive oil, and balsamic glaze.
Contorni
Secondi
Insalate
Main Courses
Entrees
Soups
Minestrone
A hearty Italian soup with mixed vegetables, beans, and pasta in a savory tomato broth.
Vegetali
Chicken
Chicken Cutlet
Crispy breaded chicken cutlet, golden-fried and seasoned to perfection.
Vegetables
Small Appetizers
Dessert Menu
Chocolate Mousse
A rich, creamy chocolate dessert with a velvety texture, topped with whipped cream and a sprinkle of cocoa powder.
Griglia E Specialita
Baked
Eggplant Parmigiana
Breaded eggplant slices baked with marinara sauce and melted cheese.
Entree
Contorni / Side Dishes
Primi
Vitello & More
Pollo
Most Popular
Starters
Menu - Contorni
Menù - Primi
Brad
Exceptional service. Good ol' fashioned Italian restaurant
Address
Reviews
Robert
The food was excellent however the wait staff was very unprofessional.
Angela
Fantastic, extremely tasty Italian food! Generous portions and plenty of seating both inside and out.
Melani
Food was delicious. We had a time crunch and the staff not only accommodated that but we're also courteous and friendly. It was a lovely atmosphere and the experience was wonderful. View menu
Jason
I had been on a streak of bad restaurant visits but this broke it. Absolutely fantastic pasta in a traditional white table cloth setting. The restaurant is warm and inviting, and so were the staff. Pretty extensive wine list. Menu is a little dairy focused for my taste. Pricing is fair especially for the area. Would definitely come back.
J
Charming decor but average uninteresting food, a weird and cagey manager/owner (the guy seems afraid of people), and unfriendly (no charm) robot servers. The only good thing was the shrimp appetizer. Although everyone in my party lives in the area, we felt this place is totally out of touch with the cool friendly vibe and quality innovative menu of the restaurants in the neighborhood.
Dont
A drink is need for the wait of freshly made food with love. Took about 15 — 20 minutes but was well worth the wait. Top to bottom: Eggplant Parmigiana with a chicken cutlet 5/5 eggplant was juicy and firm cooked evenly. Chicken cutlet- crunchy, juicy and light Sautéed Brussel Sprouts 5/5 perfectly seasoned Lasagna- Delicious, melt in your mouth, saucey Table service was a 4.5/5 Bread — fresh at first then came out colder the second round View menu
Stephanie
This place has extraordinarily terrible service, including a rude, bizarrely annoyed-seeming waiter, an unfriendly, (again) bizarrely cagey manager, and a gobsmackingly unkind owner. As for the food, it is barely passable. Context: I am a born-and-raised Manhattanite who has been going to Manhattan-based Italian restaurants (fantastic ones) for over 40 years. I've never experienced something like this place. A word to the Azzollinis: Learn from wonderful restaurants (like Lusardi's, Due, Can … – show
F
Very mediocre, definitely overpriced. Bland food, Frank's Trattoria is a much cheaper neighborhood Italian joint and more flavorful to boot. Even the bread was bad, a notch above toasted Wonderbread. Dishes that should be delicious based on their ingredients and price. The service was nothing special, and that's probably generous. The staff we interacted with had zero personality—didn't ask how we were or if we needed more wine when we finished our glasses or anything. Wine was also very overpri … – show
LordNo0b
Possibly my worst experience I’ve had at any restaurant ever. Went in with the expecting good food and amazing service like the rest of the reviews here. The food was not only undercooked and under seasoned but the staff gossip with slurs in their language (Spanish) which doesn’t encourage anyone to ask for help or to bring attention to anything that may be wrong. They spend most of their time talking and rarely checking on us. Food was absolutely disappointing. Pasta was undercooked and the tor … – show View menu
Broad Channel
Broad Channel is a small island community in Queens, known for its seafood. Locals enjoy fresh clams and fish, often prepared in simple, home-style recipes typical of the area.
Categories
-
European Delight in a culinary journey across Europe with our exquisitely crafted menu, featuring authentic dishes from France, Italy, Spain, and beyond, using the freshest ingredients to bring traditional flavors to life.
-
Ossetian Cuisine Ossetian Cuisine features traditional dishes from the Caucasus region, highlighting hearty pies filled with cheese, potatoes, or meat, warming soups, and savory grilled meats, offering a taste of rich cultural heritage. View menu
-
Caucasian Cuisine Discover the rich flavors of Caucasian Cuisine with a selection of hearty meats, vibrant vegetables, and aromatic spices, offering a culinary journey through the diverse traditions of the Caucasus region.
-
Pan-asian Cuisine Dive into a fusion of vibrant flavors from across Asia with our Pan-Asian Cuisine. Savor an eclectic menu offering a harmonious blend of traditional dishes, from sushi to stir-fry, all crafted with fresh, authentic ingredients.
Amenities
-
Wine
-
Beer
- menu
