Petee's Café - Menu

Absolutely fantastic! The guava mascarpone, which is a special spring flavor, was incredibly delicious.

Wow! I stumbled upon this restaurant by accident while visiting East Village, and it was incredible! The pies are out of this world! We sampled the sour cherry crumble and the burnt butter pecan, and they were fantastic. You have to check it out!

I miss the old pre COVID Petee’s New layout feels so constrained and weird. The pies are hit or miss for me some really go hard and others fall short. The apple crumb has been falling way short recently. Key Lime Meringue always is a slay so that’s good. View menu

The service here is genuinely five stars. Hunter, Nel, and Sage—names I remember—are incredibly warm and inviting. They go above and beyond to engage in conversation with every customer. The pie is delicious, but what truly sets this place apart is the fantastic team behind the counter. Thank you, Petees team!

Petee Cafe was an amazing experience! The staff truly understands what they're doing and they were extremely friendly. While I wasn't a big fan of the pecan pie, my girlfriend had the cheese cake pie and it was fantastic. So just choose the flavor you think you'll enjoy. This place is a hidden gem in Brooklyn and I highly recommend it.

I feel like at this point most restaurants and cafes need to have their delivery games down. While i love the pie here they often get my orders wrong when I use uber eats. Today I ordered three slices and a whole pie which came out to around $100. They instead sent four slices. Clearly a oversight that can be corrected easily but now I am holding the bag I have to call uber eats to get a refund issued because of the cafe’s mistake.But their pie is so good. View menu

Best. Pie. Ever. It was a little jarring to see all the negative 2 star reviews… not only were the pies insanely delicious but they also get 5 stars for writing descriptions [in Seamless] that are exactly on par with what you get. If you’re craving classic pie (like I was) this is your place. I feel bad when people leave poor reviews based on the opening times or the way the business is operating — times are hard, let’s not make them any harder. GREAT PIE.

3.14.23 stopped in for 3.14 pi day and had the Apple Crumb and Lemon Mirengue, both of which were really good; I think I liked the meringue the most. We also got a 12 oz drip, which was pretty good. The staff was kind and attentive while the shop had two tables that can seat parties of 2 and 4. There are also banquettes with cushions, but it's better used in conjunction with the existing tables. If anyone is wondering, the B54 stops within 2 minute walking distance going both ways.

Today I picked up an order from Petee’s. Immediately upon stepping in the pie shop I noticed the changes that have been made throughout the shop within the past two years. Uncontrollably, I mentioned what I observed and a well built man behind the counter overheard me. He was pleasantly pleased with my review and offered me a pie on the house. While I do regret not getting his name mainly because he had a ring on his finger and I don’t mingle with married men out of respect, I do wish I got his name for this review. Although I had to turn down the freebie for health reasons, I thought kind of his gesture and wanted the world to know that the customer service in this pie company is a rare tre... View menu