Sam's Southern Eatery

4837 Mahoning Avenue, Austintown, 44515, United States Of America

🛍 Cajun, Grill, Cheese, French

3.9 💬 10 Reviews

Phone: +13309530067

Address: 4837 Mahoning Avenue, Austintown, 44515, United States Of America

City: Austintown

Menu Dishes: 11

Reviews: 10

"Pretty bad. Our total for my dad 's bday dinner was 72 something. Mac and cheese comparable to the better generic boxes of shells and cheddar but I think they cooked it in a crock pot for too long and then added water before delivery. It was mush. Straight mush. The menu states a different price for gumbo but we paid 18$ for something NOT gumbo. That pic of gumbo listed in their pics is a d@%m lie. Didn 't get our extra order of slaw but the little ones that came with dinner were pretty good. Red beans rice although also super overcooked mush... the flavor was great. Fish was good. Crab cakes were crisp on the outside and mushed up mayo once bit into to. Shrimp good. They did give my dad a free PC of cheesecake and wrote happy bday which was adorable and appreciated. 3 different grown people delivered this order via Uber and I legit had to ask myself like self, could they have eaten our order and replaced it with their own dollar tree microwaved left overs? . I 'm pretty sure that didn 't happen. It was awful. The second star only added for the thoughtfulness of the bday message. Really bad. I wish we took pics. To the owners or cooks. Can we get a gift certificate for half of what we paid to please give you another shot? It was his birthday dinner. He may be getting up there in years but he can still chew. Texture is important in the food industry. Once your food is cooked (crock pots or whatever you 're doing over there) shut the heat off."

Full menu - 11 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Entrées

Salad

Seafood

Pasta

Vegetarian

Meals

Po Boys Burgers

Timothy Timothy

Food was good.

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Mary
Mary

Good food. Good service


Rachel
Rachel

the food was great highly recommend the fried green tomatoes and the shrimp people are awesome prices are good will definitely be back


Karen
Karen

The food was absolutely delicious, with generous portions and excellent service. I ordered the fish po'boy, which came with coleslaw, green beans, and mushrooms! View menu


Loco
Loco

The southern food here is outstanding! Everything is always fresh and served piping hot. I recommend placing your order about 10 minutes in advance so you can conveniently pick it up through the drive-thru. The staff and owner are incredibly friendly as well.


Tony
Tony

Not bad a little on the expensive side for what's essentially a fast food joint. Lots of chicken and fish, like a (slightly) upscale Long John's or Captain D's. $30 for a drink, an appetizer and a fried fish and crab cakes platter? No thanks. I probably wont go there again.


William
William

The food was microwaved and disappointing. I waited over 45 minutes for my meal, in addition to the 30 minutes it took for my order to be prepared before I arrived. The kitchen was very dirty, and the staff weren’t wearing gloves. Overall, it was a very unsatisfactory experience. View menu


David
David

I ordered from Sam’s for the first time today, online/picked up at window, and everything was outstanding. Food was ready on time, large portions and it tasted fantastic! I got the Tilapia with French fries and green beans, as well as some of the Gumbo to try. I will definitely be back!


Nikki
Nikki

First time ordering and I got a piece of fish, crab cake and fried green tomatoes...... Which I've never had good unless they were homemade. Until now. Everything was delicious! Would have liked the fried green tomatoes better if they were whole slices instead of half slices, but it didn't matter because they were still good. The fish was crispy outside but not dry, same with the crab cake. Nothing was soggy. Definitely can't wait to order again and try some other stuff.


Julie
Julie

Pretty bad. Our total for my dad 's bday dinner was 72 something. Mac and cheese comparable to the better generic boxes of shells and cheddar but I think they cooked it in a crock pot for too long and then added water before delivery. It was mush. Straight mush. The menu states a different price for gumbo but we paid 18$ for something NOT gumbo. That pic of gumbo listed in their pics is a d@%m lie. Didn 't get our extra order of slaw but the little ones that came with dinner were pretty good. Red beans rice although also super overcooked mush... the flavor was great. Fish was good. Crab cakes were crisp on the outside and mushed up mayo once bit into to. Shrimp good. They did give my dad a f... View menu

Categories

  • Cajun Experience the bold and vibrant flavors of Cajun cuisine with our selection, featuring spicy jambalaya, savory gumbo, and blackened catfish, each dish a celebration of the rich cultural tapestry of Louisiana.
  • Grill Succulent meats and fresh vegetables perfectly cooked over an open flame, delivering rich smoky flavors. Savor tender steaks, juicy burgers, and tangy marinated kebabs, all grilled to perfection for an unforgettable dining experience. View menu
  • Cheese A curated selection of artisanal cheeses from around the world, featuring diverse flavors and textures that delight the palate. Perfect for sharing or savored individually with the ideal accompaniments.
  • French Classic French cuisine showcasing timeless elegance, our menu offers rich and flavorful dishes crafted with traditional techniques and seasonal ingredients, promising an unforgettable culinary experience. Bon appétit!

Similar Restaurants