Scrima's Pizza - Menu

1600 E Main St, 53186, Waukesha, United States

🛍 Pizza, Pasta, Cheese, Italian

4.1 💬 191 Reviews
Scrima's Pizza

Phone: +12625445502

Address: 1600 E Main St, 53186, Waukesha, United States

City: Waukesha

Menu Dishes: 16

Reviews: 191

"Scrima's pizza is not just pizza!!! We commissioned Scrima 's to Cater My Daughter's wedding and Joe Scrima himself took care of our special day! I gave Scrima 's a 5-star review because the food and service was exceptional! The buffet included Flavorful Chicken, homemade Italian Sausage Slider (Delicious), Gluten Free Pasta Salad, Potatoes and a healthy organic Spring Mix Salad. The dessert table... There were at least 8 desserts to choose from and My personal favorite was the Cannoli Dessert. The texture was soft in the middle and crispy (with chocolate) on the outside Absolutely Wonderful! At 10 a.m. we asked that they bring out the Woodfire Pizzas and continue to exceed our expectations! When a pizza was put on the table, she was gone! There were different types of pizza (Pepperoni, Deluxe, Sausage and Cheese) and all guests enjoyed each of them! The crust on the pizza was crispy, tasteful and chewing and the toppings were well seasoned and well paired together. Thanks Joe Scrima and your excellent staff for help to make my daughter a special day a success! Joe Dequardo Waukesha WI"

Full menu - 16 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Pasta

Main Courses

Specialty Pizza'S

Dessert

Bread Rolls

Entrées

Chicken

Steamed Rice Or Noodles

Mexican Street Tacos

Pizza

Special

Scrims'S Homemade Italian Sausage

Bread

User User

This pizza is amazing !! The crust is so delicious.

Address

Show Map

Reviews

User
User

The pizza is excellent! However, it is somewhat pricey for the portion size.


User
User

The pizza here is excellent! Unfortunately, it's quite pricey for the portion sizes.


User
User

You wouldn't expect to find some of the best pizza in Waukesha inside of Woodman's but it's so good! View menu


User
User

I had a meal at Wisconsin Harley-Davidson during the rally, and it was excellent! Everyone in our group agreed that it was really good.


User
User

I had a slice of pizza at Wisconsin Harley-Davidson during the rally, and it was fantastic! Everyone in our group agreed that it was really delicious.


User
User

Delious pizza! I have eaten their pizza at least a dozen times. They are located inside the Waukesha Woodmans. I usually call ahead to have a custom take and bake pizza. They will also bake it for you if you prefer. View menu


User
User

We reached out to Scrimas and spoke directly with Joe Scrima. He was incredibly rude, insisting that in all his years of business, nothing like this had ever happened. He suggested we file an official complaint, probably to protect his insurance, but he showed no real concern for what had happened to us. As someone who works in the food industry and is ServSafe certified by the state of Wisconsin, I can tell you this is unacceptable. Food poisoning can be serious and even life-threatening, and while mistakes can happen, the way a business handles such situations speaks volumes. To argue and dismiss a customer's concerns after they've gotten sick is just bad business. I won't be purchasing...


User
User

Now, let's talk about the dessert table. There were at least eight different desserts to choose from, and my personal favorite was the cannoli. It had a wonderfully soft filling in the middle and a crunchy chocolate-coated shell on the outside—absolutely delightful! At 10 p.m., we requested the wood-fired pizzas, and they exceeded our already high expectations! The moment a pizza was set on the table, it vanished! There were several varieties, including pepperoni, deluxe, sausage, and cheese, and all the guests enjoyed them. The pizza crust was crisp, flavorful, and chewy, with well-seasoned toppings that complemented each other perfectly. Thank you, Joe Scrima, and your excellent staff...


User
User

Scrima's pizza is not just pizza!!! We commissioned Scrima 's to Cater My Daughter's wedding and Joe Scrima himself took care of our special day! I gave Scrima 's a 5-star review because the food and service was exceptional! The buffet included Flavorful Chicken, homemade Italian Sausage Slider (Delicious), Gluten Free Pasta Salad, Potatoes and a healthy organic Spring Mix Salad. The dessert table... There were at least 8 desserts to choose from and My personal favorite was the Cannoli Dessert. The texture was soft in the middle and crispy (with chocolate) on the outside Absolutely Wonderful! At 10 a.m. we asked that they bring out the Woodfire Pizzas and continue to exceed our expectations!... View menu

Categories

  • Pizza Delve into our perfectly baked pizzas, crafted with hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and a blend of gourmet cheeses. Each slice bursts with fresh toppings, ensuring a delightful bite every time.
  • Pasta Delight in our selection of classic and contemporary pasta dishes, each crafted with fresh, quality ingredients and flavorful sauces that capture the essence of Italian cuisine in every bite. View menu
  • Cheese A curated selection of artisanal cheeses from around the world, featuring diverse flavors and textures that delight the palate. Perfect for sharing or savored individually with the ideal accompaniments.
  • Italian Savor the rich and diverse flavors of Italy with our menu, offering classic pasta, savory risottos, and traditional meat and seafood dishes, all crafted with authentic ingredients and passion. Buon appetito!

Amenities

  • Takeout
  • Delivery
  • menu
  • Baked On-site
  • menu
  • Call Ahead Pickup

Similar Restaurants

Rochester Deli

Rochester Deli

143 W. Broadway Waukesha, WI 53186, United States

Menu • Beer • Delis • Bakeries • Catering


"OVERPRICED AND OVERRATED. Since Gyros West closed, we have been trying different fish fries in the Waukesha area. We ordered our food on-line. Near the end of the ordering process, there was a message regarding a surcharge for on-line orders. This notification should be near the beginning of the process. Also, this begs the question: Why should I pay a surcharge for an on-line order? When I am saving the business on labor cost by entering the order/credit card information myself. Honestly, this wasn 't a huge deal, but did start the interaction off with a bad taste in our mouths. The cod fish fry was tender and quite flavorful. We had no complaints with the quality of the product. However, the portion size was ridiculously small. It was on par with a kids meal. Each cod fish stick was consumed with only two bites. The portion size should be larger and/or the price should be lower. Out of all the many fish fries we have tried in Wauesha this one was by far the lowest on the price/value quotient. The quart of the New England Clam Chowder was very watery, lacked flavor, and had few clams. The broth should be the thick and creamy. Honestly, it appeared the Rochester Deli was running low on product and watered it down. We had to add a fair amount of Penzey 's seasonings for our taste buds. The clams were few and far between (unlike the potatoes), cut into very small pieces; but yet, were very tough and chewy. Honestly, the best part of the chowder was the oyster crackers. For our Friday fish fry needs, we have crossed off Rochester Deli from our list as there are much better options available in Waukesha. UPDATED 4/10/24 I took the time out of my busy day to submit an objective, honest review which included your New England Clam Chowder. You discredited my review by stating it was unkind and inaccurate. When I lived in Las Vegas, I had the opportunity to sample some of the world 's best chowder at the various oyster bars. I can assure you, your New England Clam Chowder on my visit, fell short on the world 's stage. I stand by my objective, honest review. Thank you, Mark"