Sir Pizza Fort Myers Shores

Holy cow! This pizza was amazing. I got the mat lovers. One of the best pizzas I have ever had.

We are Indiana natives who moved to Pine Island. We don't mind the drive to get our taste of home. Excellent pizza every time served by a warm, ...

Best Pizza around ! If you ever lived in Indiana, I'm sure you had this before. Service is Great, Food is Great and fast ! I know it will be a regular... View menu

This pizza has a unique style compared to those in New York or Chicago. The toppings are finely chopped and spread all the way to the edge of the crust, making it very flavorful.

I used to be a big fan because it was my favorite pizza from Indiana. They must've changed the recipe or owners because I got one from there last night and is didn't look or taste the same and I got sick. I'm disappointed!

Had the royal feast, wings and cheese sticks. All were fantastic. Great pizza and yes, as the reviews say, similar to pizza king in Indiana. They even had some pizza king references inside the restaurant! Excited to find this and enjoyed it all. View menu

My first time here and I must say it was the very best pizza I have ever had Im a Florida girl and My favorite place in the whole world was Upper Crust Pizza 28 Duval St Key West they had to close due to rent push out So now many years later I find my new favorite place right here

I absolutely love thin crust pizza! I ordered the Royal Feast, and it was amazing. I really enjoyed it. The staff were very friendly, and there were a lot of customers, which speaks to how popular the place is. My daughter might not appreciate my choice, though! Sir Pizza originates from Indiana, and while I was there, I had the chance to chat with people from Fort Wayne, Muncie, and Anderson—it felt like a nostalgic reunion. I've been living here for 44 years, and sometimes I find myself craving food from Indiana.

I was born n raised in Indiana, Pizza King was my first love in pizzas. When I was told by another restauranteer here in Cape that there was a franchise under the same recipes...well, we HAD to try! And OMG am I glad we did! The uniqueness of their pie is that the pepperoni is ground, not slices, so every BITE is an explosion of that lusciousness! As you can see from the photos, IT 'S LOADED! As they say at Sir Pizza, 'good to the edge '! And it won 't break the bank, large deluxe, one soda, $24. BAM! I 'm included their current menu as it really bugs me to see menus that are 2-6 yrs old on Yelp. I sure hope you folks expand to Cape Coral but until then, we 'll take the drive of 50 miles rou... View menu