Tinney's Tavern - Menu

498 Lake Desolation Road, Middle Grove, 12850, United States Of America

🛍 Lunch, Pizza, Cheese, American

4.1 💬 1117 Reviews
Tinney's Tavern

Phone: +15185848040

Address: 498 Lake Desolation Road, Middle Grove, 12850, United States Of America

City: Middle Grove

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 1117

"Friends had talked about the wood-fired pizza and baked an internet video of their pizza. But apart from one of them that had been here a few years ago under previous ownership, none of the others had. And so it was that we put the address in the GPS of our car for our first visit. The kitchen closes at 8 pm on Sunday and we came at 6:15 to an empty dining room, a nice warm wood stove, three customers sitting at the bar, a football match on a TV and NASCAR on the other. We even got a friendly “Hi!” at our entry from one employee and a “Good to see you again!” from another. When we selected one of the tables closest to the wood stove, our server informed us about two specials at night when she handed us menus. We asked what was on design and chose the Davidson Brothers Brown $4.50/pt) over three others that included a Sam Adams Oktoberfest and maybe a few Budweisers. One of the specials was an Appetizer Sampler $6) containing 4 wings, 3 mozzarella sticks, 3 onion rings and 3 chicken pliers. We ordered this while we penetrated the pizza offers. The wings were the hit on this plate crispy, fleshy and damp, with our choice of honey Habanero sauce. The plate was served with the sides of blue cheese and marinara sauces. I forgot to ask the Melba sauce for the mozzarella sticks. But the blue cheese was actually excellent on the bars, rings and tenderness. The offers had a nice bread, but the chicken was overcooked and only saved by this blue cheese sauce. The onion rings and the mozzarella sticks were typical of the frozen variety. We skipped the second special of the night, an 8 cut cheese pizza, which might have been a few dollars less than usual, so we could try the sour and pepper version $10.50). The crust edges rise nicely in the oven and have a good taste. The center of the pizza is heavily weighed with cheese. It is a really tasty cheese that is not excessively oily and easily with any piece you remove from the attempt. But the cheese will prevent you from trying to eat a slice in your hand. The house made sausages on the pizza is broken bulk, which cures in the oven, there is a crispy and contrasting texture to the cheese and dough. My preference would have been for some remarkable fennel taste in it. The thinly cut paprika seems to be looked up to the point where some are translucent. They have not added any remarkable taste. Maybe it's just that all these cheeses overwhelm the other flavors. The great discussion between my wife and me as soon as the pizza was served was, however, whether the dominant taste we experienced was smokey, carved, ashy or burned. I preferred to use the first two while my wife said it reminded them of burnt toast. If you look at the pictures I've made, you wouldn't see any burned crust. But if you looked at the bottom of a pane, you would definitely see brown and black spots. I supported my opinion that while the thick and airy crust edges had this taste, they were a beautiful golden brown. She supports her opinion on my photo of the upper vs. lower photo. The lower line is that I really enjoyed the pizza and the wings). There is probably no Rave reviews of someone who prefers a NYC style. And I would probably have stopped eating after my share of pizza, but the chalkboard of pie from Smith's orchard and Bake Shop $4.50). I chose the Blueberry over the Apple and skipped the Ala mode. It would have been better if the cooler had been removed from the cake before serving. Otherwise I still have my weakness for Smith's cake. This is a really friendly place and probably very popular with snowmobiles in winter. Hopefully, the lake will keep enough customers around in the coming year."

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Salads

Burger

Sandwiches

American Food

Dessert

Kids Menu

Chicken Wings

Main Courses

Pasta

Mixed Specialties

Wraps

Entrées

Pizza

Uncategorized

Toast

Chicken

Hot Dishes

Extras

Eggs Benedict

Soups

Chicken Dishes

Hearty Breakfast - Eggs And Omelettes

Fried Foods

Burgers, Sandwiches & Wraps

User User

Very beautiful place beautiful view

Address

Show Map

Reviews

User
User

Food is always excellent and staff is friendly!!


User
User

The wings were delicious and the beer was cold, everyone in our party loved the food!


User
User

Delicious food! The service was very friendly! Plus, the view of Lake Desolation was amazing. View menu


User
User

This was a nice find while visiting friends in Hadley. We went 2 days in a row. The Irish Benedict for brunch was amazing and the bartender was awesome! I'll be back on my next visit for sure


User
User

Wonderful atmosphere! We really enjoy their burger night special, which is only $6.50 for a cheeseburger and fries—such a fantastic deal. We like to sit at the bar while we eat! The waitstaff always ensures we have a great time. The servers are delightful, funny, and very friendly! It's a cozy spot that’s perfect no matter the season!


User
User

This place is absolutely fantastic and easily ranks among the top three meals I’ve ever had. A huge shoutout to Toni and the team for making our anniversary a memorable night. Everything we had was exceptional. The rolls came with a goat cheese butter that was simply brilliant; I’d never tasted anything like it before. We ordered a tasting menu, and everything was incredibly fresh and full of flavor. The ravioli with pork was perhaps my favorite dish. While I wasn’t as fond of one of the fish dishes, it was still quite good. The desserts were exceptional; I especially loved the baklava ice cream. The service here is unlike anything I’ve ever experienced. It was so smooth and choreographed, a... View menu


User
User

Friends had talked about the wood-fired pizza and baked an internet video of their pizza. But apart from one of them that had been here a few years ago under previous ownership, none of the others had. And so it was that we put the address in the GPS of our car for our first visit. The kitchen closes at 8 pm on Sunday and we came at 6:15 to an empty dining room, a nice warm wood stove, three customers sitting at the bar, a football match on a TV and NASCAR on the other. We even got a friendly “Hi!” at our entry from one employee and a “Good to see you again!” from another. When we selected one of the tables closest to the wood stove, our server informed us about two specials at night when sh...

Categories

  • Lunch Satisfy your midday cravings with our delicious lunch menu. From fresh salads and hearty sandwiches to savory soups and vibrant bowls, each dish is crafted to give you the perfect midday boost.
  • Pizza Delve into our perfectly baked pizzas, crafted with hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and a blend of gourmet cheeses. Each slice bursts with fresh toppings, ensuring a delightful bite every time. View menu
  • Cheese A curated selection of artisanal cheeses from around the world, featuring diverse flavors and textures that delight the palate. Perfect for sharing or savored individually with the ideal accompaniments.
  • American Enjoy classic American flavors with our diverse menu, featuring juicy burgers, crispy fried chicken, hearty BBQ ribs, and fresh salads. Indulge in timeless comfort with each bite, crafted to satisfy all tastes.

Amenities

  • Wifi
  • Delivery
  • menu
  • Parking Area
  • menu
  • Reservations

Similar Restaurants