Untamed Sandwiches - New York City (menu)

Phone: +16466699397,+16466699622

Address: 43 W 39th St, New York City I-10018-3881, United States

Menu Dishes: 26

Reviews: 1252

"How is it possible that this incredible sandwich shop has no reviews yet? If you haven't been, stop what you're doing and go now! Ideally, visit on the weekend since most of the regulars are locals who work nearby—definitely no tourists here. I can confidently say these are among the best sandwiches I've ever had; we tried four of their top sellers and I honestly can't choose a favorite. The fillings are bold and inventive, without being over-the-top or gimmicky. And the bread? It’s hearth-baked with the perfect combination of chewiness and crispiness. Plus, everything is sourced locally from New York farms, and the prices are very reasonable."

Full menu - 26 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Sandwiches/Salads

Sides

Soups

Tacos

Ensaladas

Brunch

Soda Drinks, Iced Teas

From The Fountain

Gourmet & Locally-Sourced Market Goods

Desserts

Entrées

Premium Cookie Menu

Sandwiches

Dessert

KAC

★ ★ ★ ★

As a self-proclaimed meat lover, I was pleasantly surprised by this sandwich, which exceeded my expectations for a meat-free option. It is a satisfying and flavorful meal. The charred broccoli provides a smoky taste and a wonderful texture, complemented by the sweet, smoky richness of the fried almond butter, which adds depth to the sandwich. The pickled raisin jelly introduces a touch of acidity that brightens the flavors and refreshes the palate. All of this is perfectly enclosed in a ciabatta roll that is both airy and delightfully crispy with flaky edges.

View More Reviews

Address

Reviews

Frederick

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

How is it possible that this incredible sandwich shop has no reviews yet? If you haven't been, stop what you're doing and go now! Ideally, visit on the weekend since most of the regulars are locals who work nearby—definitely no tourists here. I can confidently say these are among the best sandwiches I've ever had; we tried four of their top sellers and I honestly can't choose a favorite. The fillings are bold and inventive, without being over-the-top or gimmicky. And the bread? It’s hearth-baked with the perfect combination of chewiness and crispiness. Plus, everything is sourced locally from New York farms, and the prices are very reasonable.

Similar Restaurants

Le French Tart Deli (court St)

➤ 306 Court Street, City Of New York, 11231, United States Of America, Broad Channel

Menu • Delis • French • Italian • Catering

"I was quite surprised by some of the reviews because I had an incredible sandwich there this past Thanksgiving weekend. We were in the area and stumbled upon the place while searching for lunch, and it was our first time visiting. I ordered the Le French Baguette, and I can confidently say it was the best sandwich I've had in over a year—perhaps even longer. I'm still thinking about it and might be becoming a bit obsessed! Everything tasted incredibly fresh: the bread, the ham, the generous slices of brie, the lettuce, and the tomato. Each ingredient complemented the others perfectly, and the Dijon mustard added just the right kick. Since it was made to order, it took about 10 minutes, but it was absolutely worth the wait. I enjoyed it about 15 minutes after picking it up, and there was no sogginess at all. The portion was generous, and the price was very reasonable. Although we live in Manhattan, I will definitely be making a trip back there. I'm looking forward to it and hope they can maintain their high standards!"

San Carlo Osteria Piemonte

➤ 90 Thompson St New York, NY 10012, 10012-3739, United States

Menu • Wine • Soup • Italian • Organic

"Great atmosphere and ambiance. The setting for outdoor dining-along the river with a wonderful deck and patio-makes for a wonderful summer dining experience. Our waiter was excellent. The food was very good, but not amazing. We will definitely go back the next time we are in Bend."

Zucker's Bagels Tribeca

➤ 146 Chambers Street, City Of New York, 10007, United States Of America, City of New York

Menu • Delis • Bagels • Coffee • Cheese

"Severely overpriced, I wanted a simple bagel with salmon, it was $17 plus coffee is almost $4, I settled for a regular bagel with cream cheese and coffee and still paid $10, this is unheard of, I’m a New Yorker, a coffee and a bagel shouldn’t be over $5 together and maybe 2-3$ for fish, this place is a rip off, they also messed up my coffee, it’s not that hard to understand black coffee which they kept asking me about and still gave me milk. I’m upset, feel ripped off but I’m already out of time and have to get to work. Never coming back here again, for $20 you can have a feast for breakfast if you know your way around the city, I really wanted to give these guys a try but nope,"

Zen Ramen Sushi

➤ 150 W 36th St., New York, NY 10018, United States

Menu • Soup • Sushi • Salad • Chinese

"Love the place. Cash Only signs posted, yet a sign at the table says if you use a card you are charged 3.99% to cover credit card fees... So not sure if cards are allowed.Let's talk about the food.The seaweed salad... A dish I would normally not even touch.. I hate seaweed! However this did not taste like seaweed at all.. more like a picked cucumber salad. I really did enjoy it.The spicy beef ramen was delicious. Not too spicy, but enjoy for me to use 3 tissues to blow my nose as I was slurping the tasty broth.The outstanding roll... Lives up to its name. Would get this every single time I go back."

Loring Place

➤ 21 W 8th StNY 10011, New York, United States

Menu • Wine • Brunch • Terrace • American

"Can I eat every meal at Loring Place??? I’ve been to the restaurant maybe times in the last year and it never disappoints. The food is excellent and service above and beyond. The noise level at lunch is quiet it’s quite noisy thought at dinner. Wonderful restaurant!! I highly recommend it"

Untamed Sandwiches - Menu