Yellow Tavern - Menu

521 Church St, 47631, New Harmony, United States

🛍 Grill, Burgers, American, Fast Food

4.1 💬 1538 Reviews
Yellow Tavern

Phone: +18126823303

Address: 521 Church St, 47631, New Harmony, United States

City: New Harmony

Menu Dishes: 6

Reviews: 1538

Website: http://theyellowtavern.com/

"One member of our group ordered a Reuben sandwich, and he raved about how good it was, as he’s quite a fan of Reubens. He also got a baked potato, which was perfectly sized—not too large—and fully cooked. It's important to note that the Yellow Tavern is strictly a tavern and bar, so anyone under 21 is not permitted inside. We witnessed several families with children being informed they couldn’t stay, so keep that in mind if you're planning a visit. The atmosphere of the place is charming, with a lot of character, and the staff was fantastic—very helpful, friendly, and a lot of fun to interact with. Overall, we had a great time. Just a heads up: they do not accept credit cards. If you found this review helpful, please give it a thumbs up!"

Full menu - 6 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Sandwiches

Chicken Wings

Vegetarian

Dessert

Chicken

Ryan Ryan

The steak was excellent, and during another visit, I also tried the fried bologna.

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Jennifer
Jennifer

The food is excellent and the atmosphere is very cozy. I typically visit when I'm seeing family, and I always find myself craving the tenderloin sandwich during the trip there.


Ashley
Ashley

The food is outstanding. I've always been a fan of their pizza. It's a small, unassuming place (quite literally), but it contributes to the charm of the historic area. The service is...


Courtney
Courtney

YUM YUM! For gluten-free diet: I recommend the grilled chicken breast, no bun. Great food and atmosphere. I love the local decorations. Limited seating. Cash only for payment, but there is an ATM onsite. View menu


Alexander
Alexander

This cozy local bar is well-known for its steaks and burgers. I tried the pork chop, and it was outstanding—extremely juicy with a rich char flavor. Be sure not to overlook the bread pudding; it's a must-try!


Alan
Alan

The food and service here are excellent. It's a cozy establishment, so accommodating a group of six or more can be a bit challenging. However, the staff is very friendly and usually willing to help adjust the seating arrangements if they can.


User
User

I’ve had better pizza from gas stations. Charging $31 for frozen pizza is just not right. They also don’t inform you that they don’t accept debit cards, which forces you to use another payment method with a service fee for a subpar meal at an inflated price. Lesson learned! View menu


User
User

This restaurant does not accept debit or credit cards, but there is an ATM at the back that charges a $5 fee. I ordered a meat lover's pizza and a cheese pizza, but both lacked flavor, and the sizes were smaller than what I had ordered. I won't be returning. Tankstelle Pizza would be a better option.


User
User

The service was excellent, and the food was equally impressive. I ordered the Reuben sandwich, and it was perfectly made and delicious. Many Indian restaurants don't use the right cheese and bread for this dish, but here they nailed it. I highly recommend visiting for a great meal and fantastic desserts!


Rodney
Rodney

One member of our group ordered a Reuben sandwich, and he raved about how good it was, as he’s quite a fan of Reubens. He also got a baked potato, which was perfectly sized—not too large—and fully cooked. It's important to note that the Yellow Tavern is strictly a tavern and bar, so anyone under 21 is not permitted inside. We witnessed several families with children being informed they couldn’t stay, so keep that in mind if you're planning a visit. The atmosphere of the place is charming, with a lot of character, and the staff was fantastic—very helpful, friendly, and a lot of fun to interact with. Overall, we had a great time. Just a heads up: they do not accept credit cards. If you fou... View menu

Categories

  • Grill Succulent meats and fresh vegetables perfectly cooked over an open flame, delivering rich smoky flavors. Savor tender steaks, juicy burgers, and tangy marinated kebabs, all grilled to perfection for an unforgettable dining experience.
  • Burgers Juicy, flavorful burgers crafted with premium ingredients, from classic beef to unique vegetarian options, all served with fresh toppings and a choice of hand-cut fries or a crisp salad. View menu
  • American Enjoy classic American flavors with our diverse menu, featuring juicy burgers, crispy fried chicken, hearty BBQ ribs, and fresh salads. Indulge in timeless comfort with each bite, crafted to satisfy all tastes.
  • Fast Food Enjoy a variety of quick and delicious meals perfect for on-the-go dining. From juicy burgers and crispy fries to refreshing drinks, our fast food menu satisfies your cravings with speedy service and irresistible flavors.

Amenities

  • Takeout
  • Delivery
  • menu

Similar Restaurants