42Nd Street Sandwich
Village Deli Grill

Village Deli Grill

851 NY-211, 10941, Middletown, US, United States

Delis • Grill • Greek • Catering


"The first time, I got an egg and cheese on a roll while the deli was busy. I stood to the side and patiently waited. After about 10 minutes, I saw a sandwich wrapped in tin foil set aside by the register. The cashier completely ignored it for another 15 minutes. When I finally pointed it out, she had to unwrap the now-cold sandwich to see that it was mine and handed it to me. So, 15 minutes wasted just to receive a cold, congealed sandwich—gross. The next time, I decided to call ahead for the same egg sandwich, thinking it would be more efficient. To my surprise, it was $6 more than the previous week. I was baffled but in a hurry, so I paid and left. On my third attempt, I called ahead again. It was a quiet Sunday morning, and the cashier told me to come in five minutes. I generously gave them ten minutes before heading in. I paid, and she then informed me that the cook was still preparing my sandwich. It’s just an egg sandwich! I peeked into the kitchen, and there was absolutely no one there! For another five minutes, the kitchen remained empty. What was going on? Where was the cook making the sandwich? Finally, after a long wait, a guy strolled out of the bathroom, gave me a casual greeting, and went into the kitchen to start making my sandwich. So he spent 20 minutes in the bathroom, and now he's making my food? First off, that’s disgusting. Second, why was the cashier lying? The kitchen is visible to everyone! She could have just said it would take a bit longer and to have a seat. Instead, she claimed he was already preparing it when clearly he was not! At this point, I'm completely disgusted with the place. I have no idea if there's some kind of secret code to receive decent service that I’m unaware of. But honestly, how do you mess up such a simple order as an egg sandwich every single time?"