Bin 5 - Menu

1233 Bay St., Staten Island 10305, 10305-3120, United States

🛍 Drinks, Italian, American, Contemporary

4.6 💬 6835 Reviews
Bin 5

Phone: +17184487275

Address: 1233 Bay St., Staten Island 10305, 10305-3120, United States

City: Staten Island

Menu Dishes: 35

Reviews: 6835

Website: https://www.bin5nyc.com

"I had an absolutely amazing experience at Bin 5 and I highly recommend that everyone reading this drop what they are doing and immediately make a reservation here. I had wanted to go for a while and never made the time but I am so glad that I finally did. Every employee we spoke with was kind, attentive, and happy to answer any questions we had. The restaurant itself is beautifully decorated and feels cozy in a modern way. Every single dish that we ordered was divine, including the bread we were given in the beginning of our meal. The meatball small plate was out of this world delicious. I wish I had some right now. My family still raves about them. I also ordered the heirloom tomato salad and thoroughly enjoyed it (I've tried to copy it at home and it's never as good). My father loved his grilled salmon, especially the beurre blanc sauce, and my mother and I really enjoyed our pappardelle bolognese. Everything tasted wonderful and fresh. We also ordered the berries and cream dessert which was great and the star of the show the pistachio walnut cake. That cake was so amazing that I will never forget it. I'll absolutely be back to try some more items and order the meatballs and pistachio walnut cake again! Just a wonderful experience all around."

Full menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates on menu.

Pasta

Seafood

Salads

Entrées

Dessert

Gnocchi

Main Courses

Rice

Schnitzel

Ribs

Meat Dishes

Mexican-American Food

Pork

Fried Rice

Vegetarian

Hot Tapas

Sandwiches

Appetizer

Beef Dishes

Pasta + Entrée

Seafood Dishes

Desserts

Mains

Vegetarian Specialties

Small Plates

Daily Specials

NicoleC NicoleC

Excellent as always. Sad to see my favorite restaurant on the island close.

Address

Show Map

Reviews

Opentable
Opentable

The food was delicious and the service was exceptional! Everyone is so friendly! They make your dining experience GREAT!


Opentable
Opentable

Last night I celebrated my birthday with friends at Bin5. We all had a great time. The drinks and food were delicious!! The staff was attentive and helpful with food suggestions.


Ange
Ange

My friend recommended Bin 5 to me and I also saw their posts on Instagram and wanted to support a local business as well. I've been meaning to stop by for a while, but I'm glad I finally did to get take out. I hadn't eaten all day and was craving a burger- their Bin 5 burger definitely hit the spot. I had it cooked medium, the burger comes with cheese and bacon along with a side of fries. As you can see, I couldn't wait to get home and decided to demolish the burger in my car. Why wait? View menu


Louise
Louise

Just wow. So surprised I haven't tried this yet! So new ownership for past 6 years. The specials were cod with pistachio something or other. We got the filet mignon and scallops. Perfectly made. The octupus pineapple salsa was also phenomenal. Quite truly, they hit the mark in every aspect. Service was timely, everyone was super friendly. The outside area was beautiful, very quaint and romantically lit. A little buggy but not disruptive. Great music selection, bowie, elton john, carol king. Usually dont gush about places. We came after boxing and were in gym clothes and it was totally acceptable


Heather
Heather

Attentive, friendly and professional service! Great food and drinks! I had a reservation at 5pm on a Sunday. We were seated immediately (party of 3). The menu had so many delicious choices it was difficult to decide. We settled on trying several small plates: Burrata, Roasted Bone marrow, Breaded zucchini blossoms, Rice balls, meatballs and roasted cauliflower. All delicious with great flavor, cooked perfectly and came out timely. We had cocktails with dinner: Bee's Nees, Gold Rush and Lychee Martini... all delicious. I am definitely returning for the Degustation ASAP. Thanks Bin5... see you soon!


Susan
Susan

Why is this the first time I'm going to Bin 5 .... I'm almost afraid to find out how long I've been missing out on this delicious food. First, the place is small and cozy. The service is great. Very attentive staff. The food is phenomenal. We had the crab cakes and meatballs as appetizers and it was hard to choose because I wanted to try everything. They didn't disappoint. For mains, I had the stuffed calamari over risotto and it was delicious. My hubby had the skirt steak quesadilla. The food was plentiful so we didn't finish even half of it but had to have the pistachio walnut cake which I would go back for again and again. I will be going back again and again ! View menu


Michelle
Michelle

I have been here a few times over the years. The other night was the first time back in a few years. The service is very friendly and helpful. At first I was seated next to the door but the manager noticed I felt cold so he asked if I would like to sit in the garden which was nice. The garden is rented and heated. It was warmer in the garden. The menu is varied, there are short ribs, duck, and bone marrow on the menu which is rare on this island. My only complaint is I wish there was a fish other than salmon on the menu. There was calamari and dishes with shrimp but I would like to see something like branzino or another white fish on the menu. The cocktails are varied and mine was delicious....


Racheal
Racheal

We came here for our friend's birthday. We were greeted by the host and sat promptly. The restaurant was clean and nice with beautiful decor; they also seemed to adhere to COVID regulations of social distancing the best they could. The worker there Nicole was very nice, cool, and knowledgeable of the food. Was even able to show her a pic of food that they had on the past menu and they were able to make it. They were a bit busy and our appetizers took some time but they gave us an extra one for the wait. Which was nice of them. Our reservations were for 8pm; we got there a little after. We were seated 8:20ish, we didn't get our food until apx. 10pm (the reason for 4 stars), again they were at...


Lauren
Lauren

I had an absolutely amazing experience at Bin 5 and I highly recommend that everyone reading this drop what they are doing and immediately make a reservation here. I had wanted to go for a while and never made the time but I am so glad that I finally did. Every employee we spoke with was kind, attentive, and happy to answer any questions we had. The restaurant itself is beautifully decorated and feels cozy in a modern way. Every single dish that we ordered was divine, including the bread we were given in the beginning of our meal. The meatball small plate was out of this world delicious. I wish I had some right now. My family still raves about them. I also ordered the heirloom tomato salad a... View menu

Categories

  • Drinks Quench your thirst with our refreshing selection of drinks, from hand-crafted cocktails and fine wines to non-alcoholic delights, including sodas, juices, and expertly brewed coffee and tea. Perfect complements to your meal!
  • Italian Savor the rich and diverse flavors of Italy with our menu, offering classic pasta, savory risottos, and traditional meat and seafood dishes, all crafted with authentic ingredients and passion. Buon appetito! View menu
  • American Enjoy classic American flavors with our diverse menu, featuring juicy burgers, crispy fried chicken, hearty BBQ ribs, and fresh salads. Indulge in timeless comfort with each bite, crafted to satisfy all tastes.
  • Contemporary Contemporary cuisine embraces innovative techniques and global flavors, offering a creative blend of traditional and modern dishes designed to surprise and delight the palate.

Amenities

  • Amex
  • Beer
  • menu
  • Wine
  • menu
  • Wifi

Similar Restaurants