Phone: +19086686882
Address: 1109 South Ave, Plainfield, United States
City: Plainfield
Menu Dishes: 18
Reviews: 273
"We ordered oxtails, white rice (which the server retrieved from the back, only to warm it up in the microwave), and steamed vegetables, all of which were incredibly disappointing. The oxtails were poorly seasoned and definitely not worth the $22 price tag. Next, we tried the Escovitch fish, rice, collard greens, and steamed vegetables. The fish portion was tiny and very dry, while the rice and peas were overcooked and missing the rich flavor of coconut milk. Overall, the food lacked the authentic Jamaican flavor we were hoping for. The jerk chicken was disappointingly oven-baked and also lacked the true Jamaican seasoning and flavor we expected. It was clear that the food was not fresh; it was plated by the server in aluminum pans and then reheated in a microwave. Overall, the entire meal was bland and unappetizing. We were not informed about the individual prices of the dishes and only given the total cost of our order, which came to around $60 for three plates of unsatisfactory food. I would rate this experience a firm "0," as one star feels way too generous. I do not recommend this restaurant for authentic Jamaican cuisine; it’s simply a waste of your time and money."
Full menu - 18 options
All prices are estimates on menu.
Indian
Roti
Soft and flaky flatbread, perfect for dipping into curries or enjoying with a side of vegetables and sauces.
Chicken Curry
Tender chicken simmered in a rich, spiced curry sauce with aromatic herbs and a touch of coconut milk.
Curry Chicken
Tender chicken cooked in a rich, spiced curry sauce, perfect for a flavorful meal.
Dessert
Bread Pudding
Warm, rich bread pudding drizzled with caramel sauce and topped with a scoop of vanilla ice cream.
Entree
Starters
Meat Choices
Vegetarian
Main Dishes
Curry Goat menu
Tender goat meat slow-cooked in aromatic spices with a rich and spicy curry sauce.
Sweet Treats
Vegetarian Dishes
Carrot Cake
Moist and flavorful carrot cake topped with creamy frosting and a hint of spice.
Chicken Dishes
Bbq Chicken
Grilled chicken glazed with smoky BBQ sauce, served with a side of coleslaw and fries.
Main Courses
Fish Dinner
A hearty serving of fresh, perfectly grilled fish with a side of seasoned vegetables and a choice of rice or potatoes.
Chicken
Jerk Chicken
Spicy and flavorful grilled chicken marinated with a Jamaican jerk seasoning blend, served with rice and peas.
Appetizer
Meals
Amalia
The food at Elma's is really good, a little pricey but worth it.Food: 5/5
Address
Reviews
Lewis
I adore everything about Elma's. The food is incredibly delicious, with layers of flavor that are rich but not too salty. Food: 5/5
Derick
Good Jamaican food.....jerk chicken...BBQ chicken...curry goat .. withrice and peas...slaw and plaintain....delicious.....beef patties A plusFood: 4/5
Aliyah
I love Elma, but be cautious about ordering large quantities for delivery. They can be a bit forgetful at times. Nevertheless, their food is fantastic! View menu
Shawn
Food always good. Service can long only because people order a lot. I'm also very guilty of this. This is where I go on weekends, dates and just before drinking heavy.Food: 5/5
Emmanuel
I ordered the curry goat, but what I received was tough, rubbery, and lacked flavor. I usually prefer not to leave negative reviews for Black-owned businesses, but this was unfortunately a disappointing experience.
King
I had a terrible experience! The staff lied to me about the price of the food, even though they told the person in front of me a different price for the exact same order. The customer service was really disappointing! View menu
Rosalia
Ordered two large oxtail plates. I have to say it’s the worst I’ve ever had. There was no flavor and it actually upset my stomach to the point where I threw it up. It was so bad. And I feel like my money went down the drain. I don’t recommend this place. The food is so bad. And I’m so disappointed.
Jessie
I would give this place a zero if I could. My experience picking up my order was terrible. An older woman with short black hair was at the front, and when I greeted her, she gave me a nasty look and didn't say a word. I asked for my order again, but she continued to ignore me. If you don’t enjoy working with customers, you should consider finding a different job. I definitely won’t be returning. Additionally, the place looked dirty.
Jessie
We ordered oxtails, white rice (which the server retrieved from the back, only to warm it up in the microwave), and steamed vegetables, all of which were incredibly disappointing. The oxtails were poorly seasoned and definitely not worth the $22 price tag. Next, we tried the Escovitch fish, rice, collard greens, and steamed vegetables. The fish portion was tiny and very dry, while the rice and peas were overcooked and missing the rich flavor of coconut milk. Overall, the food lacked the authentic Jamaican flavor we were hoping for. The jerk chicken was disappointingly oven-baked and also lacked the true Jamaican seasoning and flavor we expected. It was clear that the food was not fresh;... View menu
Categories
-
Cafés Charming cafés offering a variety of freshly brewed coffees and teas, along with light snacks, pastries, and desserts. Perfect for a morning pick-me-up or an afternoon treat in a cozy atmosphere.
-
Kebab Savor our delicious kebabs, expertly grilled and bursting with flavor. Choose from a variety of meats and vibrant spices, served with fresh sides. Perfect for a satisfying and flavorful meal. View menu
-
Mexican Authentic Mexican flavors await you with sizzling fajitas, savory tacos, zesty enchiladas, and fresh guacamole, all crafted with rich, traditional spices and served with vibrant sides. Enjoy a fiesta on your plate!
-
Asiatic
Amenities
-
Delivery
-
Accepts Credit Cards
- menu
