Proper Bagel - Menu

Legit good. Everything. My fave is Avo Egg on a bialy, add bacon hash brown (see pic). Seriously I have dreams about this breakfast sandwich. Staff is rad too.

I can’t believe I hadn’t been here before. SO SO GOOD!Wait times can be a bit long, so I’d recommend going for a walk around Belmont area in the meantime or ordering ahead.

Loved this place! The best tasting bagels and cream cheese I have tried. The birthday cake cream cheese was fantastic light, sweet and not overly rich. My friend said the Nova Scotia salmon sandwich he ordered was excellent. View menu

Found this cute bagel shop on TikTok and it did not disappoint. Friendly service and amazing bagels. The owner is also amazing. Highly would recommend anyone that loves New York bagels. Thanks for a great meal and keep up the great work!!!

This place is as close to NYC bagels as you can get in the South! Everything was perfectly made to order, their flavored cream cheeses are so so good and they load it up just like it’s supposed to be. Bagels are chewy and soft, full of flavor; even the pumpernickel has bold flavor which you don’t seem to get much on the south. Been here twice now and craving more!

I have been craving a good lox bagel for a while. This did not disappoint. They offer pick up and delivery only which is fine because we were headed out of town anyway. I had the Nova Scotia salmon on an everything bagel with garlic Rosemary cream cheese…sweet baby Jesus…it was so good. This hit the spot and was perfection. The perfect chew on the bagel and amazing smoked salmon. Hubby got the Reuben on pumpernickel. He loved it and he was nice enough to let me have a small bite lol. It was delicious, I loved it paired the pumpernickel. The coffee is excellent as well. It’s a bit pricey but it’s definitely worth it. View menu

I had heard nothing but great things about this place and been wanting to try for a while. I heard the lines are usually pretty long, but on this day NOT AT ALL. Service was fast even though I was quoted 20 or so minutes to complete my order. Rosemary Garlic cream cheese and Egg with crispy bacon on Everything Bagel- 5/5; eggs were scrambled light, bacon crisp to a perfection, bagel was fresh out of the oven so it wasn't too hard to chew like some bagels. Cinnamon crunch bagel w/strawberry shortcake cream cheese- 4/5 Sweet potato mash- -5/5 it reminded me of savory baby food. I usually love sweet potatoes If you're in the Belmont area and need a nice grab and go breakfast sandwich, try them...

So I did really enjoy this experience. I just have a couple issues. The bagels are very pricey. Now I understand that you’re paying for the experience and the atmosphere so I knew that going in. I got a pop tart and the nova bagel and it was 27. The wait time is also Very long. But this is still a must try location.They have tons of options and even vegan options. The staff was VERY nice and ONTOP OF IT which given the crowd today was very impressive. The bagel itself was a little hard but Im also not bagel connoisseur so maybe New York style is supposed to be hard on your moth? ?‍So…long story long if you’re willing to wait a long time and pay a lot of for a New York style bagel this is you...

This place should be 5 stars. The food is EXCELLENT, amazing sausage, good bagels, and overall a solid restaurant experience.However, their customer service leaves a lot to be desired. I just picked up an online order for my girlfriend, and watched as they took other people’s orders and walked around the restaurant multiple times calling their name. Not once was my GFs name called. After being 15 minutes behind the due time I finally ask if the order is ready. It was, it was just sitting back there for 15 minutes. I ordered online, why was my order not placed on the metal racks? Why was my order not tried again and again to find its customer? The runners kept walking up to other people and a... View menu