8Oz Sirloin
1847 At The Stamm House

1847 At The Stamm House

6625 Century AvenueWI 535622225, Middleton, United States

Fish • Pizza • Sushi • Seafood


"Can’t say enough about our dining experience. Was a reunion of 4 couples school friends plus significant others. First off, the place is farmhouse gorgeous. Beautifully restored. Started at the bar where most of us got their specialty drinks, which were delicious and quite strong. Also an order of cheese curds that we all thought were excellent perfectly gooey with a very light, tempura like batter. Super friendly bartenders. Had dinner upstairs and while it was initially cold, especially by the window it is a stone building , they brought up a heater which warmed things up nicely. Many had the prime rib special, which they seemed to enjoy. I had the walleye, which was fine. The breading was crispy and the fish was moist and tender, but it was not particularly flavorful. My boyfriend had the cod. I never think to order cod as it doesn’t itself have flavor, but this cod was in the most delicious butter sauce with mussels. It was divine and because he had a flight out the next day, I got all the leftovers to myself!! We were too full for dessert, but two of us shared a peanut butter chocolate martini, made with peanut butter whisky ?! which we passed around and which was divine. I’ve never had anything like it. It starts off tasting like a regular chocolate martini but then finishes with the peanut butter flavor. Spectacular. I wish I remembered our servers name, but she was so personable and attentive. Separate checks was not a problem. I would highly recommend this place for a gathering for friends or family or even a cozy dinner for two. Will be back when in town."