"I have left previous reviews about the Nautilus, have been dining at this restaurant for the last 20 years. I am always amazed at the consistency. Food always perfectly cooked, arrives hot and is excellent quality. Seafood, steaks, always spot on. I consider myself a pretty picky customer as use to dine out often on my job at many high end places. Service is always courteous and efficient. Meals here are usually quick in terms of turning around the tables, but the dining room is smaller and I personally do not like to spent hours sitting waiting for service. I do not feel rushed while here, but usually in and out (with reservation) in about 90 minutes. In closing just amazed I have never had a bad meal or bad experience at the Nautilus Cafe in all my years dining here. Guess that is why dining room always full. Definitely a Long Island South Shore Gem!"
