"After poor dining experience for my wife's 80th birthday at our oceanfront hotel next door the night before, we tried The Reserve. Fantastic! Our server Kaylon, I think is correct, was a pro, with a personality. Menu with ample excellent choices. Everything served at the appropriate moment, hot and perfectly prepared. Oysters Rockefeller, Crab cakes, bacon-wrapped sea scallops, redfish, traditional caesar salad, key lime pie, each delicious.Our third trip to Jekyll Island, will return st least twice each year, Lord willing, and we will make The Reserve our first dining choice as long as they keep to this same standard."