"After hearing about Jimmy Buffet's passing, we finally decided to check out this restaurant. Unfortunately, it quickly reminded us why we had never visited before. After a long hour wait, we entered to find the place looking quite dirty, with many tables still uncleared. We assumed they were just understaffed.
Once seated, it took quite a while for our server to bring us water. We had a special deal on food, but the server was unaware of the specifics. It took two inquiries before she finally went to get clarification.
We ordered an appetizer platter, coconut shrimp, shrimp and grits, and a margarita. The appetizer platter was underwhelming and certainly not worth the over $22 price tag. The coconut shrimp, also over $22, came with only five pieces and a small serving of fries. It was bland and more batter than shrimp. For half the price, you could buy better coconut shrimp at Walmart, with a more favorable shrimp-to-batter ratio.
The shrimp and grits were decent but not remarkable. It had more shrimp than the coconut shrimp, and the sauce was flavorful, yet it still didn’t justify the over $20 price.
The only highlight of the meal was the margarita. The $11 watermelon margarita was refreshing, not overly sweet, and had a fantastic watermelon flavor. If I ever return, it will only be for the margaritas during happy hour. Otherwise, I won't waste my money again at Margaritaville. As some have said, paying $86 for mediocre food, poor service, and a dirty environment is indeed a waste, and I can't disagree. This experience was entirely my own mistake."
