Large Pie 16
Jimmy Tomato's

Jimmy Tomato's

123 E Main St, 07834, Denville, United States

Pizza • Lunch • Salad • Italian


"I love a good slice of pizza but really really love a jimmy's pizzas!! The bombay veggie (red sauce one is our default pizza any day of the week (see my pics . It is the best vegetarian pizza we have ever had because it has the right amount of veggies and sauce! We've tried just about all of the Indian style pizzas (except the chicken and jain ones as we are in the company of veggie eaters who love garlic and onions (jain versions are made with no meat, garlic or onion . That said, I will say that we love all of their Indian style and paneer pizzas as they fit the variety of spicy moods we may find ourselves in. The achari pizzas have a hot and sour flavor, which is from the mixture of the red achari Indian spices sprinkled on top and the tiny pineapple bits for the sour piece. If you've ever had an Indian mango pickle, the achari red spice will be a very familiar and welcome taste to you. The corn pizza is an explosion of corn with a great amount of cilantro as well, which is brilliant. What I find unique with the Indian pizza options is the dough. It's not a Brooklyn style dough that's floppy, but it's as thin as one. It's an ever so slightly fluffy thin pizza with a crisp bottom for the small and medium size. The edge or crust of the pizza is always crispy and crunchy delicious, too. If you go for the large size, the dough towards the center is a bit more like a brookly style, meaning not as crisp and will bend from the amount of ingredients. Non the less we still love it. Not all of their pizzas are like the Indian style ones as they do sell traditional pizzas as well that are more expected/typical dough or Brooklyn style with a thin chewy dough. I definitely recommend ordering from jimmy's at least once and trying the Indian ones if you can handle some spice as they all have a spicy red sauce, if not a jalapeño topping to add more heat. It's the Indian pizzas that kept us coming back. They have gotten a bit more expensive lately as the pricing has gone up over the years, especially if you order for delivery. They don't offer coupons or deals anymore it seems as well as I didnt see any of the off peak specials posted, and so we're cutting down as it is a bit and a drive for us. I do wish they had a reward system for loyal customers as I'd sign up."