"This review is for the pizza itself. I ordered carry-out and have no thoughts on the service. This pizza has to be the most overrated pizza I’ve had in my life. Given the high reviews, I’m extremely disappointed. I’m coming from Milwaukee, where I had 5 times the pizza options available to me in half the distance and 4/5 of the price. With Glass Nickel’s status and price, I was expecting the best pizza I’d had in my life. Instead, it’s mediocre at best. The crust was overpowering. 60% of the flavor came from the crust. I got regular crust, as that’s what I normally order. I would highly recommend only ordering thin crust from Glass Nickel. They don’t put enough sauce or toppings on the pizza to make regular crust a good crust experience. I didn’t expect to be chewing through a wall of crust for a smidgeon of flavor. They say “100% Wisconsin Cheese” like that’s something special. You think that isn’t true of every pizza joint, even the chains? Meanwhile, in my opinion, it is some of the least flavorful cheese of all of the pizza places. I would expect at least 30% more sauce and cheese than I received. I’m not trolling when I say, in my opinion, Glass Nickel is the 2nd-worst pizza in town. Only better than Little Ceasar’s. Stunningly, worse than Papa John’s. I recommend all Glass Nickel staff try a Papa John’s cheese, compared to a Glass Nickel cheese. Try an $11 Costco cheese. Glass Nickel is worse. I guess, it didn’t instantly give me acid reflux, like Little Ceasars, but beyond that, I’ve never been more disappointed with a pizza."
