Monterrey Chicken
Johnny V's Classic Cafe

Johnny V's Classic Cafe

1650 S 84th St Milwaukee, WI 53214-4433, United States

Diners • Italian • American • Breakfast


"Recently went back to Johnny Vs for their AYCE shrimp special.. got the peel and eat shrimp. Ordered it around 7:45pm, so it wasn't close to closing time. Our server brought my wife's meal (she had the tour of Italy special, I believe it's caled- she liked her meal) and my meal around 8pm. Everything's great, salad was good, shrimp is made just right. Server comes back around 20 minutes later.. doesn't offer more shrimp, indicates that she can take our plates away.. Uhh, I paid $18 for my shrimp dinner for a reason- because it was all you can eat. I had to ask for more shrimp, and did get it 45 minutes after we arrived.. That was the first weird moment. The second weird moment was when I was done with my second plate of shrimp.. mind you, these aren't huge plates they use for the refills, so it's not like I ate a ton more shrimp. The server comes to our table and says she can have the bill ready for us whenever we're done. Again, seeing my empty AYCE should tell most servers to offer me more shrimp, right? She didn't. I was kinda upset that she did that to me twice. A person orders AYCE and has an empty plate, as a server you're supposed to offer another plate. I don't know if Johnny Vs was low on shrimp last night or what, but if they were- just TELL ME when I'm ordering that they have limited quantities. Will I be back ton Johnny Vs? Of course. This incident was just worth mentioning if you ever plan on going there for their AYCE specials.. Personally I think it's more than that but I won't speculate on that here."