"I'm not sure what went wrong with my first order; maybe it was the New York-style crust. However, I've tried the hand-tossed option several times since, and it is by far the best pizza in the city. The cookies and cheesecake are fantastic as well. For those who claim that all pizza is good pizza, they clearly haven't experienced this place. While it looks decent, the store-bought, stale crust was a huge letdown. The tomato sauce tasted like it came straight from a can, and there was an overwhelming amount of grease. I can't decide if this or a cheap pizza from Amazon is worse. Considering this was $15 compared to $3 for the Amazon one, I can confidently say this is the worst pizza I've ever had."