Quinoa Parfait
240° West

240° West

269 Fontana Boulevard, Fontana-on-Geneva Lake, 53125, United States Of America, Fontana-on-geneva Lake

Seafood • American • Steakhouse • Gluten Free


"Went for a romantic bday dinner. I ordered the cosmopolitan to start because the table next to me had one and it looked amazing. I got mine and it looked nothing like that. It was in a smaller glass, different color and lemon instead of lime. When the waiter asked how it was, I mentioned it didn’t look anything like the one I saw. He did confirm it was also a cosmo, but they have different size glasses. Weird since there was only one price on the menu. He offered to bring me another one in the bigger glass. I was like ugh yeah! It came and still didn’t look anything like the other one. Tasted more like a vodka cranberry. I just left it at that and ordered their prime rib Saturday special. When it came, I couldn’t believe what was delivered to our table. Looked nothing like prime rib. Mor like sirloin steak or a very thin New York strip. We ordered it med rare. This was med at best. No flavor, dry. Just terrible. The manager came over and agreed it was not appetizing looking and did take both our meals off the bill along with that first cosmo. I have had prime rib many places and make it at home as well. Never had an experience like that. This is supposed to be a finer dining restaurant at a resort in lake Geneva. I just couldn’t believe that was even allowed to leave the kitchen. Ruined our experience and will never go back to The Abbey Resort."