"My wife and I grew up in the area and visit Sag Harbor frequently. We had not been to Tutto il Giorno previously, but decided to try during our recent stay and celebration of our wedding anniversary. The seating is very packed and we found ourselves in a small 2by wedged on a corner next to a “seating/waiting” area in they center on the main room. It was ok, but really poorly situated. A lot of traffic and cramped. The service was OK, no more than average. The Burrata appetizer was very good, which sparked expectations of a good experience. I decided to try the Cioppino, one of the pricier dishes in the menu. My wife had an eggplant dish which was reasonably good. The cioppino was overcooked. The shrimp and calamari were rubbery, as was the lobster. The muscles were done well. The sauce was flavorless. Mention of the issue to the server showed little concern. Definitely not worth the $70+ price for the dish. We will likely not return during our stays in the area, nor recommend to others."
