"They offer lemonade, fruit punch, and iced tea for $2, and when I asked if they made it themselves, I was told yes. However, when we tasted it, it turned out to be just powdered flavored water. I had expected something homemade, but I suppose for $2, that wasn't realistic.
We ordered the "Great Catch" for $40, which includes shrimp, fish, chicken wings, and lobster, along with two sides. Unfortunately, they were out of lobster and offered to double the fish and shrimp instead. I requested the shrimp to be sautéed, and they said it would take about 25 minutes. After waiting 40 minutes, we finally received our food. We took it home, which is a 30-minute drive, and the order included 3 pieces of fish, 7 shrimp, a handful of fries, and some broccoli, but no chicken wings.
To my disappointment, the fish was hard as a rock, overly salty, and some pieces even smelled off. The shrimp, which I had asked to be sautéed, were fried instead and also excessively salty. The broccoli was decent, but it would have been nice to have more. The fries were bland, which was surprising given the over-seasoning of everything else. They were greasy and there weren't many, either.
Compared to other seafood places in the area, this one falls short. For example, Surf City in Jersey City offers a fried fish platter for $33 that includes 4 pieces of cod, around 10 shrimp, calamari, and plenty of fries, all of which are tastier and a better value.
Disappointed, I called the restaurant to mention they had forgotten the chicken wings. At that time, I hadn't tried the fish, so I didn't mention it was bad. The staff member assured me they would credit some money back to my card. However, a few days later, the charge went through, and I received no credit.
After reading through more reviews, I noticed that others have also mentioned missing items, such as mac and cheese. If you decide to eat here, I highly recommend checking to ensure they pack everything correctly."
