Fish Soup Fish Soup
Collage

Collage

60 Hypolita St, St. Augustine, USA, United States

Cafés • Seafood • American • Ice Cream


"Though the food might be good, the service was bad and the atmosphere was lackluster. For a place to have such high recommendations and reviews this place fell very short of expectations. I took my gf here for her birthday and was excited to take her here. Made the reservations and even selected birthday as the occasion. When we got to the restaurant our table hadn 't been cleaned off, nobody said happy birthday or even asked what the occasion was. The waitress was not polite and made it seem like we were an inconvenience for wanting to ask a question that may have taken 1 or 2 minutes of time. Now I understand that if a place can hold over 200 people is packed and you are rushing around, then yes I can understand being rushed, but this place holds maybe 25 people max at a given time. We also wanted to try something and asked the server her opinion and the server acted like it would be gross if we ordered it, that is distasteful and just made my gf upset. I even tried talking to the manager about the experience and just didn 't get anything in response and so we left hungry. I get this place might have good food but let 's be honest, you can find good food anywhere and especially in a place like st augustine. When you are spending $100 per person you are paying for the experience and are looking to enjoy yourself, this place falls way short of that. St augustine has many great restaurants and if you are actually looking for a nice place that you will enjoy then I urge you to look elsewhere."

Carlito's

Carlito's

20 Sherman Hill Rd, 06798, Woodbury, US, United States

Pasta • Cheese • Italian • Ice Cream


"we have been going to carlito for several years. we supported them during covid by consistently ordering them. twice in the last months was my eating sub par. for the first time, my court almost tasted like a soap plate. it was sent back, and I got another court, but it was after my fiancée just over ended his court. tonight we went there, and I ordered a garnel Sampi court for $28.00 I received the court with seven garnel and no more than 10 strands pasta. I asked why so little pasta when pasta is the cheap part of the meal. the court was withdrawn and returned with a tonne pasta, which was pumped on the court, now not tasteful (watery,) because no more sauce was placed on pasta. my fiancée spoke to one of the owners, and everything she said was regrettable. if I pay almost thirty dollars for a meal, I expect it to be perfect. Last time I was told that there were new chefs, well, they didn't make it better. bring back the old cooks or cooks who know what they are doing. that's a hit for carltios, not sure if we make a strike again. soouu disappointing! we loved this place, and now we really don't want to go back. if a meal is not correct, is it not to the owner to do good at the meal? we were not offered anything at all. very poor art, business, carltos! start the training of their chefs we know are not chefs to do better. they will lose good customers like us who do not think of paying when the meal is good."