Columbus Public House

Gilligan's

➤ 64 N Main St, Sherburne, NY, 13460, United States

Carta • American • Fast Food • Ice Cream • North American

---

"I wish this place was more consistent : When it's good it's really good, but for us it's hit or miss and we order the same thing every single time. We're creatures of habit like that lol Today I got literally 1/2 the size of the chicken they normally put on the sandwich. So I had to rip 1/2 the bun away to even kinda enjoy it for the CHICKEN sandwich it was supposed to be! :"

Bullthistle Brewing Company

➤ 45 S Main St, Sherburne, NY, 13460, Village of Sherburne, United States

Carta • Pub • Breweries • Sandwiches • Pub Kitchen

---

"During our visit to Bullthistle Brewing Company in Sherburne, we had a rather disappointing experience. After looking through the menu and selecting our flatbreads, we were unaware that we needed to order at the bar, as the sign indicating this was quite small and not very noticeable. We ended up waiting at our table for an additional 20 minutes without any staff member informing us of the ordering process. Although the bartender glanced at us several times, we felt ignored and ultimately decided to leave. With only two other couples in the establishment, a simple announcement about ordering at the bar would have been helpful. While I might consider giving them another chance in the future, I would recommend that they clearly state the ordering procedure on the menu for better customer understanding. This experience was unfortunate, but it's a valuable lesson to steer clear of places with such unwelcoming attitudes."

Lewis'

➤ 93 North Main Street, Village Of Sherburne, 13460, United States Of America

Carta • Food • American • Fast Food • North American

---

"Delicious food, but be ready for a wait! We visited Lewis' Restaurant for the first time, eager to see if it lived up to the hype from the reviews. I made a reservation and arrived a few minutes early, but ended up waiting 22 minutes to be seated. To make it more frustrating, another table without a reservation was seated before us. The restaurant was bustling and quite noisy. While I usually don't mind slower service during busy times, I felt somewhat overlooked, aside from when our food was delivered. My drink order came without lemon, but another staff member helped with that after I asked. I attempted to get a soda refill, but the fountain wasn't working properly, leading to another 20-30 minutes of waiting—again, no lemon. As for the food, the salads were average, mainly consisting of iceberg lettuce, which was a bit disappointing. The salads included thinly sliced onion, cucumber slices, and cherry tomatoes, and the dressing was good. The warm bread was a little too squishy, making it difficult to spread the cold, hard butter on without completely squishing the bread. We ordered Utica greens, which were quite tasty, and I would certainly order them again, despite the slightly higher price than expected. My companion chose a special of creamy risotto with shrimp, which was delicious! I had the stuffed shells with meatballs. The meatballs were excellent, and the shells were good, but I wished they had more filling. The sauce was superior to what you typically find in restaurants. We had to ask the hostess for takeout containers and the bill. I prefer to box my leftovers myself, so I wasn’t thrilled when she took our plates to the back to box them up. It took quite a while to get them back along with the check. In total, we spent almost two hours from the moment we entered until we left. Lastly, I recommend dressing in layers, as it can be quite chilly inside the restaurant."