Elm Street Oyster House

I absolutely loved this restaurant! The service was excellent and the food was delicious. I will definitely be returning in the future.

The playlist for the background music may be suitable for the bar crowd, but it was too loud and too thumping for eating dinner and having a conversation.

I was at this restaurant last week and it was great. I had a half dozen clams and a half dozen oysters as an appetizer before my dinner, and it was fantastic. Ver carta

The food was delicious. I was a bit disappointed that the paella did not have true andouille sausage in it (that I’m used to). It was still a great dish. I will be going back again.

The food at this restaurant is terrible, especially if you enjoy meat dishes. However, the service is good. I would recommend avoiding this place. The dining experience was for dinner, with a price range of $50-100 per person. The food quality was rated 1, service was 5, and the atmosphere was 4.

The best Paella!!! Great atmosfere and great service. Loved it. I live in Queens, NY, but I will gladly drive back to Greenwich just for the Paella! Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $100+ Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Brussels Sprouts, Paella, Crab Cakes, New England Clam Chowder Ver carta

Wonderful lunch. Great oysters from MA and superb lobster rolls. As good a lobster roll as I have had in a long long time. A wonderful service lady who answered every question and well you could not do better anywhere else For us we learned of the restaurant fro our daughter who lives in Westchester. We live in northern NJ but only 32 minute drive. We absolutely will return.

We found ourselves at this restaurant on a weekday afternoon for a late lunch and chose to sit outside. The service was good, the food was decent but overpriced. The portions were generous, and the burger was tasty. For those with dietary restrictions, the wait staff was able to provide gluten-free options although the menu was not marked. Overall, we would rate the food a 3, service a 4, and atmosphere a 2. The price per person was between $50-100 for lunch.

Great space for a small gathering of 4-6 people or less. Visited on Sunday around 12:30 and there was a small crowd but it got busier as more people filtered in after. I ordered oysters which tasted pretty fresh, and for my entree, the shrimp with garlic mashed potatoes and broccoli rabe. The mashed potatoes is actually one of the best I've ever had! I would visit the again just for that, haha. My husband ordered fish which was great and the buffalo shrimp which was pretty pricey as there were 3 shrimp for the small price of $20 . Apart from the slow service, the dining experience was great and we would definitely return. Ver carta