Michelangelo Pizzeria

Always great! First pizza i had when I moved to the area and it is still a guilty pleasure years later

Very, very good. The cook is a Hispanic guy, who might be mistaken for Italian. Anyways, he's an excellent guy, great cook. Try the grilled chicken sandwich, excellent!

Finding good pizza in Florida can be tough, which is why I keep returning to this place. It's a fantastic spot for families, and the quality of the food is exceptional for everyone. Ver carta

Absolutely! This is the best pizza in Sarasota. The restaurant is spotless, and the food tastes amazing. We will definitely return! I highly recommend this place for a fantastic meal.

We ordered the Nona Pie and gorgonzola salad a few days ago, and it was absolutely delicious! As pizza enthusiasts from Connecticut, we were genuinely impressed with this pizza. It's definitely the best I've had in Florida. Great job!

We had a reservation for 7:45, but upon arrival, we were told that dine-in service ended at 7 and the restaurant would close entirely by 8. They refused to seat us. I was confused as to why we were able to book a table through the app if they were going to turn us away. It was their error, not ours, and I was shocked by how they managed the situation. Ver carta

We had a reservation for 7:45, but when we arrived, we were told that dining ended at 7 and the restaurant would close completely by 8, so they couldn’t seat us. It was confusing why we were able to book a table through the app if this was the case. Being turned away due to their error was very frustrating. The entire experience was truly disappointing.

Fantastic pizza!! The gentleman who took my take-out order over the phone was very polite, and I believe he was the same one cooking. I’m originally from Connecticut, just outside of New Haven...I grew up having some of the best pizza in the country. Since I’ve lived in Florida I have not had a good white broccoli pizza, but this place changed that for me! We also had a traditional red pizza that was seasoned perfectly. The crust was flavorful and cooked just right! Their prices are also very fair. This will be our families go-to place for pizza from now on!

A new neighbor invited me over for Christmas dinner, and I was thrilled that our unconventional meal turned out to be my favorite Italian dish: Eggplant Parmesan! And it was overseen by Michelangelo's, which made it even better. Eager for more, I decided to order two Eggplant Parmesan dinners for delivery to fuel me while I studied for a professional exam. I ended up with the main dish, an order of meatballs, angel hair spaghetti, a few rolls, and some side salads. Essentially, I was set for three days with this meal! Everything was top-notch, delicious, and truly satisfying. The meatballs were incredible—each one was about the size of a quarter-pound hamburger or bigger! I specifically aske... Ver carta