Olde Mill Tavern - Carta

Pizza Gourmet

➤ 599 E Boston Post Rd, 10543, Mamaroneck, United States

Carta • Pizza • Salads • Italian • American

---

"I had an amazing experience at this restaurant in Mamaroneck. The food was outstanding, the owner and employees were wonderful, and the prices were very reasonable considering the quality of the food. I highly recommend this place and wish I could visit more often. The pizza was exceptional and the sandwiches were delicious. The service was top-notch, and the overall atmosphere was great. I would give this restaurant a 5-star rating for both food and service. The average price per person for lunch was between $10 and $20."

25 North

➤ 974 E. Boston Post Rd. Mamaroneck, NY 10543, 10543-4123, United States

Carta • Beer • Pasta • Cheese • Italian

---

"First timer at 25N so was open minded. But I am a bit of a cynical critic and only occasionally write a review. Was a pleasant surprise they have valet parking. Seemed as if only 1 guy but arriving and leaving was easy and good. Simple floor sign at front door redirects to enter thru tent in the back. Was actually nice to walk in that way and check out the outdoor seating which is nicely enhanced by stone walls across the rear. Was Friday night and outdoor tables were booked on the OT app but looked like couple of tables available so I asked. Young man (Jose) receiving us reminded me of the rain forecast and noted the tent is protecting but suggested indoors is the better option. He was right! Split levels interior suggested origin of the restaurant was a private home but did not matter. Another young man provided very nice waiter service all night (with a team) from start to finish. This was just myself and my son and daughter (both college age). We were enjoying ourselves and the food which was standard upscale restaurant caliber but truth be told every dish was over salted. Every! Again, we were in good moods, enjoying our time together, enjoying overall good food and totally accommodating service all around. A bit of an isolated location (not a walk around after dinner area) but in the end very nice!"

Nonna Carola

➤ 211 AveNY 10543, Mamaroneck, United States

Carta • Cafés • Cheese • Italian • Chicken

---

"Great atmosphere whether you are seated indoor or out in their patio. The service was very professional and helpful. Always appreciate when food arrives hot enough to stay warm throughout the meal, as was the case here. Everyone in our party enjoyed their meals and we would all give Nonna Carola high marks in all aspects."

Al Dente Pizzeria

➤ 7 Elm Pl, Rye I-10580-2918, United States

Carta • Kebab • Cafés • Pizza • Italian

---

"Meal Type: Dinner Price Range: $1–10 I had an excellent dining experience! The food was top-notch, earning a full five stars for its quality. The service was equally impressive; the staff was attentive and friendly, making me feel valued throughout my visit. The atmosphere of the restaurant was delightful, creating a pleasant environment for dinner. As for parking, there was plenty of space available, and I appreciated the free street parking option. Overall, a fantastic experience that I would highly recommend!"

Le Provençal Bistro

➤ 436 AveNY 10543-2613, Mamaroneck, United States

Carta • Wine • Cafés • Pizza • French

---

"This spot is a cozy spot for dinner! It's very clean and the servers are very kind and welcoming. I didn't get the name of my server but he was very funny and was very helpful in deciding dishes. I got the Beef Bourguignonne, Lobster Bisque, French Onion Soup, Seafood Risotto, Crème Brûlée and the Bread Pudding. I can't quite remember which cocktail I ordered but it was light and refreshing. It was my first time having Beef Bourguignonne and I enjoyed it very much. The meat was tender and pulled apart so easily and the green beans were nice and crunchy. This would be the dish I'd come back for! The seafood risotto was a generous portion and equally delicious. There were many bits of seafood which I appreciated and the creaminess of the risotto made me want to eat more and more of it. I loved the plating of it as well! The only dish I wasn't the biggest fan of was the lobster bisque. I was expecting it to be creamy but it was very watery. I ended the night with 2 desserts which were the crème brûlée and bread pudding with ice cream. My favorite was the bread pudding. It tasted like a warm cake and pairing it with the ice cream made it all that much tastier. It was the perfect dessert to end the meal. This is a great spot for a romantic date night! Highly recommend you check it out and make your reservations!"